Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

12-Year-Old Heart Patient Denied Transplant Over Vaccine Status

2/16/2025

40 4

Summary

Story summary

Adaline Deal, a 12-year-old from Indiana, faces a heartbreaking setback as Cincinnati Children's Hospital denies her a crucial heart transplant due to her unvaccinated status against COVID-19 and flu. Her parents, adhering to their religious beliefs, refuse vaccinations despite her dire health. In a show of support, a GoFundMe campaign has already raised over $50,000 to seek treatment elsewhere.

History

Historical Context

Adaline Deal's denial for a heart transplant due to her unvaccinated status reflects ongoing debates over medical ethics and patient rights. Historically, cases like the Tuskegee Syphilis Study and the Cruzan case have highlighted the importance of informed consent and the ethical treatment of patients. These precedents underscore the tension between individual rights and institutional policies in healthcare decisions.

1 of 2

Story summary

Adaline Deal, a 12-year-old from Indiana, faces a heartbreaking setback as Cincinnati Children's Hospital denies her a crucial heart transplant due to her unvaccinated status against COVID-19 and flu. Her parents, adhering to their religious beliefs, refuse vaccinations despite her dire health. In a show of support, a GoFundMe campaign has already raised over $50,000 to seek treatment elsewhere.

1 / 2