Story perspectives

Noem Sparks Outrage, Calls Canada '51st State'

3/5/2025

39 6

Summary

Story summary

Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem ignited outrage during her January visit to the U.S.-Canada border in Vermont. By crossing a tape line and proclaiming "U.S.A. No. 1," she dismissed Canada as "The 51st state." Her remarks drew sharp criticism from Canadian officials and locals, highlighting the growing strain in U.S.-Canada relations.

History

Historical Context

Kristi Noem's remarks at the U.S.-Canada border echo historical tensions in U.S.-Canada relations, particularly during the War of 1812 when national identities clashed. Her comment about Canada as "The 51st state" reflects a long-standing perception of American exceptionalism. This incident highlights the fragility of diplomatic ties, reminiscent of past disputes over trade and border security that have periodically strained relations between the two nations.

1 of 2

Story summary

Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem ignited outrage during her January visit to the U.S.-Canada border in Vermont. By crossing a tape line and proclaiming "U.S.A. No. 1," she dismissed Canada as "The 51st state." Her remarks drew sharp criticism from Canadian officials and locals, highlighting the growing strain in U.S.-Canada relations.

1 / 2