Story perspectives

New York Court Rules Non-Citizens Can't Vote

3/20/2025

49 4

Summary

Story summary

In a decisive 6-1 ruling, the New York Court of Appeals has struck down a city law that would have allowed non-citizens to vote in municipal elections. This decision reinforces the principle that voting rights are reserved for U.S. citizens, thwarting efforts to empower over 800,000 non-citizens, as Republican officials swiftly challenged the 2022 law.

History

Historical Context

The New York Court of Appeals' ruling against non-citizen voting echoes historical debates over voting rights in the U.S. In the 19th century, states restricted voting to white male property owners. The Voting Rights Act of 1965 expanded access, yet contemporary challenges persist, reflecting ongoing tensions between inclusion and traditional citizenship criteria in American democracy. This ruling reinforces the long-standing principle of citizenship as a prerequisite for voting.

1 of 2

Story summary

In a decisive 6-1 ruling, the New York Court of Appeals has struck down a city law that would have allowed non-citizens to vote in municipal elections. This decision reinforces the principle that voting rights are reserved for U.S. citizens, thwarting efforts to empower over 800,000 non-citizens, as Republican officials swiftly challenged the 2022 law.

1 / 2