Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

Bob Keller Rates 'Land of Bad' 5/10; Praises 'Black Hawk Down'

4/7/2025

41 9

Summary

Story summary

US Army expert Bob Keller gave "Land of Bad" a lukewarm 5/10, pointing out its tactical flaws despite showcasing impressive gear. In stark contrast, Ridley Scott's "Black Hawk Down" soared with a 9/10, celebrated for its gripping authenticity and heartfelt soldier testimonials from the harrowing 1993 Mogadishu mission.

History

Historical Context

The contrasting reviews of "Land of Bad" and "Black Hawk Down" reflect ongoing debates about military representation in media. Historically, films like "Top Gun" and "Saving Private Ryan" shaped public perceptions of the military, often emphasizing heroism. In contrast, critiques of war films, especially post-Vietnam, have highlighted the need for authenticity, as seen in Ridley Scott's portrayal of the 1993 Mogadishu mission.

1 of 2

Story summary

US Army expert Bob Keller gave "Land of Bad" a lukewarm 5/10, pointing out its tactical flaws despite showcasing impressive gear. In stark contrast, Ridley Scott's "Black Hawk Down" soared with a 9/10, celebrated for its gripping authenticity and heartfelt soldier testimonials from the harrowing 1993 Mogadishu mission.

1 / 2