Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

Trump's Deportation Plan Threatens Habeas Corpus Rights

5/15/2025

28 4

Summary

Story summary

The writ of habeas corpus, a vital safeguard against unlawful detention, is under threat as President Trump, via Stephen Miller, contemplates its suspension to speed up deportations. Legal experts warn that only Congress holds the authority to suspend this fundamental right, highlighting its essential function in curbing executive power in America.

History

Historical Context

The current threat to habeas corpus echoes historical tensions during the Civil War. President Lincoln suspended this right in 1861 to detain suspected traitors without trial, leading to the landmark case Ex parte Merryman, where Chief Justice Taney ruled that only Congress could suspend it. This conflict between executive power and civil liberties remains relevant as legal experts warn against unilateral actions by the executive branch today.

1 of 2

Story summary

The writ of habeas corpus, a vital safeguard against unlawful detention, is under threat as President Trump, via Stephen Miller, contemplates its suspension to speed up deportations. Legal experts warn that only Congress holds the authority to suspend this fundamental right, highlighting its essential function in curbing executive power in America.

1 / 2