Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

Ruling Sparks Debate on Transgender Prisoner Rights

5/20/2025

50 4

Summary

Story summary

In a significant ruling, Sheriff Thomas Millar declared that calling trans women men is not transphobic, amidst the trial of Alexandria Stewart, a male-born killer. The court dismissed abuse claims by inmate Jane Sutherley, igniting a heated debate over the safety and housing of transgender prisoners in women's facilities, following a contentious Scottish government policy.

1 of 1

Story summary

In a significant ruling, Sheriff Thomas Millar declared that calling trans women men is not transphobic, amidst the trial of Alexandria Stewart, a male-born killer. The court dismissed abuse claims by inmate Jane Sutherley, igniting a heated debate over the safety and housing of transgender prisoners in women's facilities, following a contentious Scottish government policy.