Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

Trump's Federalism: Power Centralization Sparks State Conflict

6/11/2025

26 3

Left

Noah Critiques Trump

Timothy Noah passionately critiques Trump's brand of federalism, asserting it favors harm over help. He points out the erratic federal response to immigration protests and natural disasters, revealing a troubling decline in support for states. This centralization of power not only undermines states' rights but also intensifies conflicts, especially with California, which is contemplating withholding federal taxes.

Right

Bass Faces Turmoil

Los Angeles is engulfed in turmoil as Mayor Karen Bass grapples with escalating violence and public safety concerns. Critics claim she and fellow Democrats are disconnected from the community's needs, highlighted by a CBS poll revealing that 54% back Trump's immigration policies. The National Guard's presence is deemed essential for national security, not an overreach of federal power.

Center

Newsom Challenges Trump

California Governor Gavin Newsom has taken a bold stand against President Trump, filing a lawsuit over the deployment of National Guard troops without state approval. He argues this move violates the 10th Amendment and misrepresents peaceful protests as "rebellion." Newsom insists that local law enforcement is capable of handling the situation, underscoring the vital role of state authority in policing.

1 of 3

Noah Critiques Trump

Timothy Noah passionately critiques Trump's brand of federalism, asserting it favors harm over help. He points out the erratic federal response to immigration protests and natural disasters, revealing a troubling decline in support for states. This centralization of power not only undermines states' rights but also intensifies conflicts, especially with California, which is contemplating withholding federal taxes.

1 / 3