Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

Fans Outraged Over Adam Fox's NHL Ranking

8/15/2025

50 3

Summary

Story summary

Adam Fox is ranked 16th among defensemen by NHL Network, causing fan outrage over perceived unfairness.
He achieved a goals above replacement (GAR) of 15.5 but placed 12th in Norris Trophy voting.
Cale Makar is ranked first, followed by Quinn Hughes, who faced injuries last season.
The situation underscores varying perspectives on player evaluations and the influence of team performance.

History

Historical Context

The NHL's introduction of the "Goals Above Replacement" (GAR) metric in 2018 reflects a growing trend in sports analytics, where statistical evaluations increasingly challenge traditional player assessments. Adam Fox's GAR of 15.5 exemplifies this debate, echoing past controversies over player rankings, such as those surrounding the 2017 list of the 100 Greatest NHL Players, which sparked significant discussion among fans and analysts alike.

1 of 2

Story summary

Adam Fox is ranked 16th among defensemen by NHL Network, causing fan outrage over perceived unfairness.
He achieved a goals above replacement (GAR) of 15.5 but placed 12th in Norris Trophy voting.
Cale Makar is ranked first, followed by Quinn Hughes, who faced injuries last season.
The situation underscores varying perspectives on player evaluations and the influence of team performance.

1 / 2