Full Breakdown
Pittsburgh Steelers' Quarterback Situation: Trade Rumors and Roster Decisions
8/26/2025, 7:36:28 PM
Current Quarterback Landscape
The Pittsburgh Steelers are navigating a complex quarterback situation as the 2025 NFL season approaches. With Aaron Rodgers signed for what is likely his final season, the team is assessing its long-term options behind him. The recent injury to rookie quarterback Will Howard, who fractured a bone in his throwing hand, has further complicated matters. Reports suggest that Howard may start the season on injured reserve, which would open the door for Skylar Thompson to secure a spot on the 53-man roster.
Skylar Thompson's Preseason Performance
Skylar Thompson has emerged as a strong candidate for the backup role after a notable preseason. He completed 41 of 56 passes for a 73.2% completion rate, throwing four touchdowns and only one interception. This performance has led some fans and analysts to advocate for Thompson over Mason Rudolph, who struggled with two interceptions during the preseason. However, insiders indicate that Thompson may still be cut, with Rudolph likely retaining the No. 2 spot.
Trade Speculations
As the Steelers finalize their roster, trade rumors are swirling around Thompson. With the Las Vegas Raiders in need of a backup quarterback following Aidan O'Connell's wrist injury, Thompson could be seen as a viable trade option. The Raiders are reportedly looking for an experienced player to fill their backup role, and Thompson's playoff experience could make him appealing. Additionally, the Indianapolis Colts are also exploring trade options for their quarterback Anthony Richardson, which could indirectly affect the Steelers' plans.
Kenny Pickett's Trade to the Raiders
In a related development, the Raiders recently acquired Kenny Pickett from the Cleveland Browns for a fifth-round pick. This move was prompted by O'Connell's injury, leaving the Raiders in need of a reliable backup behind starter Geno Smith. Pickett, a former first-round pick by the Steelers, has had a tumultuous career, being traded multiple times in just a few seasons. His experience could provide stability for the Raiders, but it also highlights the shifting dynamics in the quarterback market.
Official Statements & Responses
Steelers General Manager Omar Khan has expressed optimism about the team's quarterback depth, stating, "I feel really good about that receiver room," while also acknowledging the need for a reliable backup. Meanwhile, Raiders head coach Pete Carroll emphasized the importance of acquiring an experienced player to support Smith during the season.
Criticism & Opposition
Despite Thompson's impressive preseason, some analysts argue that his performance came against lower-tier competition, suggesting that he may not be ready for a significant role in the NFL. Steelers insider Mark Kaboly stated, "Let’s just stop this nonsense about Skylar Thompson being the No. 2 quarterback because he’s played better than Rudolph," indicating skepticism about Thompson's ability to secure a permanent spot.
What's Next
As the Steelers finalize their 53-man roster by August 26, all eyes will be on the quarterback decisions. The potential for trades involving Thompson or other players remains high, especially as teams across the league seek to bolster their quarterback depth. The Steelers' ability to navigate this situation effectively could have significant implications for their performance in the upcoming season.
