Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

New 'Roses' Film Lacks Satire, Criticized as Toothless

8/30/2025

40 3

Summary

Story summary

"The Roses," directed by Jay Roach, is criticized for lacking the dark satire of the 1989 original.
Reviewers describe the film as "toothless" and "weak-willed."
Comedic performances by Andy Samberg and Kate McKinnon disrupt the film's pacing and tone.
The characters are portrayed too sympathetically, undermining the original's satirical intent.
The adaptation lacks the expected high stakes of a toxic marriage narrative.

History

Historical Context

The 1989 film "The Roses," directed by Mike Nichols, offered a dark satire on toxic relationships, resonating with audiences and grossing over $20 million. Its recent adaptation by Jay Roach, set to release in 2025, has been criticized for softening the original's critique, reflecting a trend in modern cinema where comedic elements often overshadow serious social commentary, potentially diminishing the genre's impact.

1 of 2

Story summary

"The Roses," directed by Jay Roach, is criticized for lacking the dark satire of the 1989 original.
Reviewers describe the film as "toothless" and "weak-willed."
Comedic performances by Andy Samberg and Kate McKinnon disrupt the film's pacing and tone.
The characters are portrayed too sympathetically, undermining the original's satirical intent.
The adaptation lacks the expected high stakes of a toxic marriage narrative.

1 / 2