Full Breakdown
Dodgers' Closer Tanner Scott Faces Scrutiny Amid Struggles
9/9/2025, 4:27:53 PM
Overview of Tanner Scott's Performance
Tanner Scott, the Los Angeles Dodgers' closer, has encountered significant challenges in his first season with the team after signing a four-year, $72 million contract. Despite a promising track record with the Miami Marlins and San Diego Padres, where he recorded a 1.75 ERA and 22 saves in 2024, Scott's performance has deteriorated. Currently, he holds a 4.56 ERA with an alarming nine blown saves, the highest in Major League Baseball.
Recent Struggles and Consequences
Scott's recent outings have been particularly troubling. In a critical series against the Baltimore Orioles, he allowed walk-off hits in back-to-back games, contributing to the Dodgers' losses. On September 6, he surrendered a walk-off home run to rookie Samuel Basallo, and the following night, he gave up a two-run single that sealed another defeat. These performances have raised questions about his reliability in high-leverage situations.
Manager Dave Roberts has acknowledged the team's struggles, stating, "I also live in a world of, ‘What’s the alternative?’" This sentiment reflects the lack of viable options in the bullpen, as the Dodgers have not found a suitable replacement for Scott. Roberts emphasized the importance of trust and experience in his bullpen, noting that many of the alternatives have limited major league experience.
Official Statements & Responses
Roberts has expressed a commitment to giving Scott opportunities despite his recent failures. He stated, “These are the guys we signed off on, we believe in... But they’ve got to – you’re talking about winning 11 games in October, getting there obviously, and guys that you can trust in that hot box of moments.” This indicates that while Scott's performance is under scrutiny, the team is still backing him for the time being.
Criticism & Opposition
Critics have been vocal about Scott's performance, particularly after the recent losses. Many fans expressed their frustration during games, with loud boos directed at Scott when he allowed hits that ended no-hitter bids. The Dodgers' bullpen as a whole has struggled, with a collective ERA of 4.40 over the past month, further complicating the situation for Roberts and his coaching staff.
What's Next for the Dodgers?
As the Dodgers approach the postseason, they face the urgent task of solidifying their bullpen. With Alex Vesia expected to return from the injured list, the team may need to reassess Scott's role. The upcoming weeks will be crucial for determining which pitchers can be trusted in high-pressure situations, as the Dodgers aim to secure their playoff position.
Verbatim Quotes
- “It feels terrible. I have to figure it out because baseball hates me right now.” — Tanner Scott, Dodgers Closer
- “What's the alternative?” — Dave Roberts, Dodgers Manager
- “These are the guys we signed off on, we believe in,” — Dave Roberts, Dodgers Manager
In summary, Tanner Scott's performance has become a focal point of concern for the Dodgers as they navigate the challenges of the season. With the postseason on the horizon, the team's management must make critical decisions regarding their bullpen strategy.
