Story perspectives

Yankees Face Tough Decision on Shortstop Volpe

9/10/2025

Summary

Story summary

The New York Yankees must decide on shortstop Anthony Volpe as the postseason approaches.
Manager Aaron Boone backs Volpe but may consider José Caballero due to Volpe's struggles.
Volpe has a .207 batting average and 19 errors, raising questions about his future.
Insider Joel Sherman forecasts Caballero starting in the playoffs, indicating a strategic shift.
The Yankees' playoff hopes depend on difficult roster choices, putting Volpe's position at risk.

History

Historical Context

In 1978, the New York Yankees replaced struggling shortstop Bucky Dent, who had a .225 batting average, with a more reliable player, a decision that significantly impacted team performance. Fast forward to 2023, Anthony Volpe's .207 average and 19 errors reflect similar challenges, as the Yankees grapple with balancing player development and competitive needs, ultimately missing the postseason for the first time since 2016.

1 of 2

Story summary

The New York Yankees must decide on shortstop Anthony Volpe as the postseason approaches.
Manager Aaron Boone backs Volpe but may consider José Caballero due to Volpe's struggles.
Volpe has a .207 batting average and 19 errors, raising questions about his future.
Insider Joel Sherman forecasts Caballero starting in the playoffs, indicating a strategic shift.
The Yankees' playoff hopes depend on difficult roster choices, putting Volpe's position at risk.

1 / 2