Full Breakdown
Ivan Toney Defends Saudi Pro League's Quality Amid Criticism
9/10/2025, 7:45:36 PM
Toney's Transition to Saudi Arabia
Ivan Toney, the 29-year-old striker, made headlines when he transferred from Brentford to Al-Ahli in the Saudi Pro League in the summer of 2024 for £40 million. Since then, he has scored 35 goals in 48 appearances, contributing significantly to Al-Ahli's success, including winning the AFC Champions League and the Saudi Super Cup. Toney's performance has sparked discussions about the quality of the Saudi Pro League compared to more established leagues like the Premier League.
Claims of League Quality
Toney has publicly stated that he believes the Saudi Pro League is "on par" with the Premier League. He asserts that if Al-Ahli were to compete in the Premier League, they would be "close to the top four." He cites Al-Hilal's recent victory over Manchester City in the FIFA Club World Cup as evidence of the league's competitiveness. Toney emphasized that the league should not be dismissed, arguing, “It is a quality league and people should not turn their noses up.”
Adapting to New Challenges
Toney has acknowledged the unique challenges of playing in Saudi Arabia, particularly the extreme heat, which he describes as akin to playing in a sauna. He noted that adapting to the climate requires different tactics and game management, stating, “There are different blocks of 20 minutes where it is intense and then naturally it has to slow down and pick up again.” His adaptation has been crucial for his performance, as he finished as the second-top scorer in his debut season.
Official Statements & Responses
Despite Toney's impressive form, his move has not positively impacted his international career. He has been excluded from recent England squad selections, including for World Cup qualifiers against Andorra and Serbia. Toney remains hopeful for a recall, stating, “If I am selected, I will do my best for my country but if not, I’ll be cheering the boys on.” He maintains that his focus is on performing well for Al-Ahli, believing that consistent scoring will enhance his chances for national selection.
Criticism & Opposition
Toney's assertions regarding the Saudi Pro League have drawn skepticism and criticism from various quarters. Some fans and commentators have questioned the validity of his claims, suggesting that the league's overall quality does not match that of the Premier League. Comments on social media reflect a range of opinions, with some dismissing Toney's statements as part of a narrative pushed by the league to enhance its reputation. Critics argue that the league's attendance figures and the presence of high-profile foreign players do not equate to a competitive standard comparable to the Premier League.
What's Next for Toney and Al-Ahli
As Toney continues to adapt and thrive in the Saudi Pro League, he aims to lead the scoring charts this season and help Al-Ahli secure more victories. He also anticipates that growing interest from players in joining the league could further elevate its profile. Toney's journey reflects a broader trend of players exploring opportunities in emerging football markets, despite the ongoing debates about the quality and competitiveness of these leagues.
