The Paper: Reviving the Mockumentary Format

The Paper, a spinoff of the acclaimed sitcom The Office, premiered on Peacock on September 4, 2025. Set in the same universe as its predecessor, the series follows the struggling Toledo Truth-Teller newspaper and its efforts to regain relevance. The show features Domhnall Gleeson as the new editor-in-chief, who faces challenges in revitalizing the publication with the help of volunteer reporters, including Oscar Nuñez reprising his role as Oscar Martinez, now an accountant at the newspaper.

Hollywood Reporter

The Paper's cast includes Oscar Nuñez, Ramona Young, Gbemisola Ikumelo, and Alex Edelman. The show was co-created by Greg Daniels, who also developed The Office, and Michael Koman. Koman explained that the concept arose from the idea of a documentary-style show centered on a struggling newspaper, which resonated with him. He appreciated the connection to The Office, noting that the characters would be aware of the original documentary's existence.

Hollywood Reporter

To celebrate the show's launch, the cast hosted a pop-up event outside 30 Rockefeller Plaza in New York City, where they distributed bagels and posed with newspapers inspired by the show. This event aimed to engage the public and generate excitement for the series.

Hollywood Reporter

The Paper has been well-received, with all ten episodes currently available for streaming on Peacock. The series has already been renewed for a second season, indicating strong viewer interest. Critics have highlighted Sabrina Impacciatore's performance as Esmeralda Grand, the managing editor, noting her ability to blend humor with depth, making her character both frustrating and relatable.

Forget 'The White Lotus,' Sabrina Impacciatore Just Gave the Funniest TV Performance in Years

Oscar Nuñez remarked on his return to the franchise, stating, “They’re doing OK, no one’s starving. I think they’re happy for me,” reflecting a positive atmosphere among the cast. The show's creators have expressed their excitement about continuing the legacy of The Office while exploring new comedic avenues.

Hollywood Reporter

While the show has garnered praise, some critics question whether the mockumentary format can sustain its charm without becoming repetitive. TheWrap discussed this concern with Greg Daniels and Michael Koman, who acknowledged the challenge of balancing humor and authenticity in the genre.

‘The Paper’ Creators Share Their ‘Strict Rules’ for Breaking the 4th Wall

With its renewal for a second season, The Paper is set to continue exploring the dynamics of the Toledo Truth-Teller and its staff. Viewers can anticipate further character development and comedic scenarios as the series progresses.

5 Best New TV Shows to Stream This September — The Office Spinoff, Crime Dramas, Psychological Thrillers, and More

• “I also really liked the idea that this documentary exists — the original Office documentary exists in our world so our characters would know what it looks like to be filmed at work over a period of years.” — Michael Koman, Co-Creator

Hollywood Reporter

The Paper aims to blend nostalgia with fresh storytelling, appealing to both fans of The Office and new viewers alike.

Hollywood Reporter