Full Breakdown
NHL Pre-Season Fan Survey Reveals Opinions on Rule Changes and Player Dynamics
9/14/2025, 4:05:19 AM
Fan Perspectives on NHL Rule Changes
As part of The Hockey News’ pre-season fan survey, a significant focus was placed on the NHL's rules, particularly regarding the shootout, overtime, and fighting. The survey revealed that fans are divided on several key issues. Notably, 50.5% of respondents favored removing the shootout, while 49.5% wanted to retain it. Many fans suggested extending overtime as a potential alternative to the shootout, with Ottawa Senators goaltender Linus Ullmark advocating for an additional five minutes of play.
Fans also expressed a desire to change the delay-of-game penalty for flipping the puck over the glass, with suggestions to treat it similarly to icing. The trapezoid rule, which restricts goaltenders from playing the puck behind the net, was another point of contention, with many fans wanting to see more freedom for netminders. Additionally, the survey indicated that 55% of fans believe referees should hold post-game press conferences to explain controversial calls, while 45% disagreed.
Opinions on Fighting Penalties
Regarding fighting in the NHL, the majority of fans (approximately 80%) preferred to maintain the current five-minute major penalty for fights. The survey allowed fans to vote on whether penalties should be lighter or heavier, but most opted to keep the status quo. This reflects a general acceptance of fighting as part of the game, despite some leagues, such as the QMJHL, banning it altogether.
Player Dynamics: The Future of the Chicago Blackhawks
In a separate discussion, the Chicago Blackhawks are navigating a challenging rebuilding phase, particularly with the recent contract extension of goaltender Spencer Knight. Knight, who has only 95 games of NHL experience, will see his salary increase to $5.83 million for the 2026-27 season. Despite his potential, the Blackhawks face significant challenges in depth and talent, especially compared to Central Division rivals like the Colorado Avalanche and Dallas Stars.
The Blackhawks have not made the playoffs for five consecutive seasons, and the upcoming season is expected to follow a similar trajectory. While Knight's contract provides stability, the team still has numerous roster gaps to fill, making a quick return to playoff contention unlikely.
Rookie Race: Celebrini vs. Bedard
As the NHL season approaches, the competition for the Calder Trophy is heating up, particularly between rookies Macklin Celebrini of the San Jose Sharks and Connor Bedard of the Chicago Blackhawks. Both players had impressive performances last season, with Celebrini scoring 25 goals and 63 points in 70 games, while Bedard recorded 23 goals and 67 points in 82 games. Projections for the upcoming season suggest that Bedard may have the edge, with expectations of reaching 82 points, compared to Celebrini's projected 70 points.
Conclusion: The Road Ahead
The NHL's pre-season fan survey highlights a variety of opinions on rule changes and player dynamics, reflecting the diverse perspectives of hockey fans. As teams prepare for the upcoming season, the Blackhawks' rebuilding efforts and the rookie race will be closely monitored, setting the stage for an intriguing NHL campaign.
