Story perspectives

New Evidence Emerges in 2005 Cruise Ship Disappearance

9/14/2025

48 8

Summary

Story summary

George Smith disappeared from Royal Caribbean’s Brilliance of the Seas on July 5, 2005, during his honeymoon, resulting in a mishandled crime scene.
His wife, Jennifer Hagel, has filed a lawsuit against the cruise line, claiming a cover-up.
Blood evidence in Smith's cabin contradicts the cruise line's narrative of an accidental fall.
The unresolved case raises concerns about the FBI's investigation closure and absence of arrests.
CBS recently re-aired a 2011 episode on the case, reflecting continued public interest.

1 of 1

Story summary

George Smith disappeared from Royal Caribbean’s Brilliance of the Seas on July 5, 2005, during his honeymoon, resulting in a mishandled crime scene.
His wife, Jennifer Hagel, has filed a lawsuit against the cruise line, claiming a cover-up.
Blood evidence in Smith's cabin contradicts the cruise line's narrative of an accidental fall.
The unresolved case raises concerns about the FBI's investigation closure and absence of arrests.
CBS recently re-aired a 2011 episode on the case, reflecting continued public interest.