Story perspectives

Debate Erupts Over Political Violence on 'The Five'

9/16/2025

Summary

Story summary

Greg Gutfeld and Jessica Tarlov debated political violence on "The Five," with Gutfeld asserting it is mainly a left-wing issue.
Tarlov highlighted the murder of Minnesota Democrat Melissa Hortman, challenging Gutfeld's viewpoint.
Gutfeld countered that Hortman's murder was personal, not politically motivated, and noted the lack of prior attention to her case.
The discussion intensified after the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk.
Gutfeld's comments sparked social media reactions, with some supporting his position against Tarlov.

History

Historical Context

The assassination of Senator Robert F. Kennedy in 1968, following Martin Luther King Jr.'s murder, underscored a surge in political violence in the U.S., with incidents increasing by 50% that year. This historical context resonates today as debates, like those between Greg Gutfeld and Jessica Tarlov, reflect ongoing challenges in addressing political extremism and its impact on societal discourse.

1 of 2

Story summary

Greg Gutfeld and Jessica Tarlov debated political violence on "The Five," with Gutfeld asserting it is mainly a left-wing issue.
Tarlov highlighted the murder of Minnesota Democrat Melissa Hortman, challenging Gutfeld's viewpoint.
Gutfeld countered that Hortman's murder was personal, not politically motivated, and noted the lack of prior attention to her case.
The discussion intensified after the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk.
Gutfeld's comments sparked social media reactions, with some supporting his position against Tarlov.

1 / 2