Full Breakdown
Kaleb Johnson's Kickoff Return Blunder Leads to Demotion
9/17/2025, 12:05:18 PM
Incident Overview: Costly Mistake in Week 2
Pittsburgh Steelers rookie running back Kaleb Johnson has been removed from kickoff return duties following a significant error during the team's Week 2 loss to the Seattle Seahawks. In the fourth quarter, with the Steelers trailing 17-14, Johnson failed to field a kickoff from Seahawks kicker Jason Myers, allowing the ball to bounce into the end zone. Under NFL rules, a ball that lands between the goal line and the 20-yard line and then goes into the end zone must be returned or downed; otherwise, it remains live. Seahawks player George Holani recovered the ball in the end zone for a touchdown, extending Seattle's lead to 24-14 and contributing to the Steelers' eventual 31-17 defeat.
Coach's Response: Mike Tomlin's Assessment
Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin addressed the media on Tuesday, indicating that Johnson "probably" would not return kicks in the short term. Tomlin expressed his belief in Johnson's talent and work ethic but emphasized the need for the rookie to demonstrate improvement through consistent daily work. "You’ve got to man up, you got to acknowledge your shortcomings, and then you got to work to move beyond it," Tomlin stated. He reiterated that Johnson would have the opportunity to earn back his role but must first prove himself.
Johnson's Reaction and Future Prospects
After the game, Johnson acknowledged his mistake, stating, "I just made a mistake. Got to stick to it, move on, and just continue to get better every day." Despite his demotion, he remains hopeful about regaining his position. Johnson, who was drafted in the third round after a standout college career at Iowa, has struggled to make an impact in his early NFL games, recording only two carries for -1 yard in the first two weeks.
Potential Replacements for Kickoff Duties
With Johnson sidelined from kickoff returns, Tomlin has not yet confirmed who will take over the role. Running back Kenneth Gainwell is currently the primary returner, while Trey Sermon, who returned kicks during the preseason, is on the practice squad. Receiver Roman Wilson also has experience returning kicks from his college days at Michigan.
Criticism and Opposition: Concerns Over Johnson's Readiness
Critics have pointed out that Johnson's lack of experience as a returner—having only 15 returns in college—may have contributed to his blunder. Some analysts argue that his skill set as a power runner does not align well with the demands of kickoff returns, raising questions about his suitability for the role. Furthermore, Johnson's performance in the preseason, where he appeared hesitant and unsure, has led to skepticism regarding his readiness for the NFL.
What's Next: Steelers' Upcoming Challenges
As the Steelers prepare for their Week 3 matchup against the New England Patriots, they will need to address not only the special teams situation but also injuries affecting their defensive lineup. Key players, including edge rusher Alex Highsmith and defensive lineman Isaiahh Loudermilk, have been ruled out, which could further complicate their game plan. Tomlin's focus will be on monitoring Johnson's progress and determining the best course of action for the team's special teams moving forward.
