Full Breakdown
B.J. Penn Arrested for Fifth Time in 2025 for Violating Restraining Order
9/17/2025, 10:20:31 PM
Overview of the Incident
UFC legend Jay Dee "B.J." Penn, 46, was arrested on September 15, 2025, for violating a court-ordered restraining order filed against him by his mother, Lorraine Shin. This marks Penn's fifth arrest this year, as confirmed by the Hawaii Island police. Officers responded to a report of a violation at a property on Puueo Street in Hilo, where they determined that Penn had entered in violation of the protective order, which prohibits him from contacting his mother or being within 100 yards of her residence. Following his arrest, Penn was charged and later released on $2,000 bail.
Background of Legal Issues
The restraining order was put in place after a series of troubling incidents between Penn and his mother. In May 2025, Penn was arrested twice for allegedly abusing Shin, including an incident where he reportedly shoved her against a vehicle and stole her mail. Following these events, Shin filed for the restraining order, citing "extreme psychological abuse" and expressing concerns about her son's mental health. She suggested that Penn might be suffering from Capgras delusional syndrome, a psychiatric disorder where an individual believes that a close family member has been replaced by an identical imposter.
Family Dynamics and Allegations
Shin's allegations against her son include claims that he has engaged in bizarre behavior, such as removing her belongings from their home and tampering with her security systems. She reported that upon returning from a trip, she found her possessions missing and her security cameras covered with duct tape. Penn has denied these accusations, asserting that he is being falsely portrayed and that his mother is an imposter. In a recent Instagram post, he referred to the restraining order as "first-degree theft."
Official Statements & Responses
The Hawaii police issued a statement confirming Penn's arrest and detailing the circumstances surrounding the violation of the protective order. They noted that Penn was arrested without incident and that he had been charged with violating the order for protection. Penn has not publicly commented on this latest arrest, but his previous social media activity has raised concerns about his mental state.
Criticism & Opposition
Critics of Penn's behavior, including his family members, have expressed deep concern for his mental health. Lorraine Shin has described her son's actions as indicative of a serious psychological disorder, emphasizing the need for medical intervention. The family has voiced fears for their safety, citing Penn's erratic behavior and delusional claims about family members being replaced by imposters.
What's Next
B.J. Penn is scheduled to appear in court on September 24, 2025, for a conference hearing related to the ongoing legal issues stemming from his arrests and the protective order. The outcome of this hearing may determine further legal actions and the potential for mental health evaluations as suggested by his family.
Verbatim Quotes
- “He believes I’m an imposter who has killed his family to gain control of the family assets.” — Lorraine Shin, Mother
- “Hawaii Island police arrested and charged 46-year-old Jay Dee ‘B.J.’ Penn of Hilo, for violating a court order for protection,” — Hawaii Police Statement
