Quarterback Performances Under Scrutiny in Week 4

As the NFL enters Week 4 of the 2025 season, quarterback performances are under intense scrutiny, particularly for players like Baker Mayfield, C.J. Stroud, and Daniel Jones. The fluctuating nature of their performances has sparked discussions about their effectiveness and potential for improvement.

QB Stock Market Week 4: Baker Mayfield Has A Superpower. Where Did C.J. Stroud's Go?

Baker Mayfield, quarterback for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, has demonstrated a unique blend of chaos and control on the field. Despite some missed opportunities, including overthrows that could have led to touchdowns, Mayfield orchestrated a game-winning drive against the New York Jets. His ability to adapt under pressure and deliver crucial plays has contributed to his rising stock in the quarterback rankings, positioning him as a key player to watch this season.

QB Stock Market Week 4: Baker Mayfield Has A Superpower. Where Did C.J. Stroud's Go?

In contrast, C.J. Stroud of the Houston Texans is facing challenges that have led to a disappointing start to the season. After a promising rookie year, Stroud has struggled to find his rhythm, throwing for no more than 207 yards in any game this season and accumulating more interceptions (three) than touchdown passes (two). Analysts attribute part of his struggles to a lack of support from the offensive line and limited receiving options beyond Nico Collins. This has raised concerns about his development and effectiveness moving forward.

Forbes

On a more positive note, Daniel Jones has revitalized his career with the Indianapolis Colts, leading the team to a 3-0 start. His work ethic and dedication have been praised by teammates and coaches alike. Jones ranks highly in several key statistical categories, including completion percentage and passer rating, and has shown significant improvement against the blitz compared to his previous seasons with the New York Giants. His performance has sparked discussions about his potential candidacy for the Comeback Player of the Year award.

New York Times

While Mayfield and Jones are experiencing upward trends, Stroud's performance has drawn criticism from analysts who question his ability to adapt to the NFL's demands. The Texans' offensive struggles, particularly the lack of a strong supporting cast, have been highlighted as significant factors in Stroud's underwhelming performance. Critics argue that without substantial improvement, Stroud may not fulfill his potential as a franchise quarterback.

Forbes

Coaches and teammates have expressed confidence in their quarterbacks. Colts coach Shane Steichen emphasized Jones' meticulous preparation and ability to execute plays effectively. Conversely, Texans coach DeMeco Ryans acknowledged the challenges Stroud faces but remains hopeful for his development, citing the need for improved offensive line performance and better utilization of receiving options.

New York Times

• “Danny Dimes, man, he’s balling again. … He’s damn near (the) Comeback Player of the Year already,” — Charvarius Ward, Veteran Cornerback

New York Times

• “I know as receivers, they want to catch touchdowns, they want to catch the ball.” — Mike Vrabel, Patriots Coach

New York Times

As the season progresses, all eyes will be on these quarterbacks to see if they can maintain or improve their performances. Mayfield will look to build on his momentum, Stroud will aim to turn his season around, and Jones will strive to continue his impressive start against tougher opponents. The outcomes of their upcoming games will be crucial in shaping their narratives for the remainder of the season.

Forbes