Story perspectives

Judge Rules FEMA's Conditions Unconstitutional, Boosts States' Rights

9/25/2025

Summary

Story summary

U.S. District Judge William Smith ruled the Trump administration's FEMA-cooperation requirement unconstitutional.
He sided with 20 Democratic-led states, a move praised by Rhode Island Attorney General Peter Neronha.
The ruling follows a suit alleging the administration unlawfully withheld billions in disaster relief funds.
DHS argued the conditions were necessary to enforce immigration law but failed to justify them.

History

Historical Context

In 2018, the Trump administration's policies limited disaster relief funds based on immigration status, affecting states like California and Texas. FEMA faced backlash for withholding over $3 billion in aid, impacting thousands of disaster victims. Judge William Smith's recent ruling highlights a growing judicial resistance to federal overreach in disaster management, potentially influencing future cases on disaster relief and immigration enforcement.

1 of 2

Story summary

U.S. District Judge William Smith ruled the Trump administration's FEMA-cooperation requirement unconstitutional.
He sided with 20 Democratic-led states, a move praised by Rhode Island Attorney General Peter Neronha.
The ruling follows a suit alleging the administration unlawfully withheld billions in disaster relief funds.
DHS argued the conditions were necessary to enforce immigration law but failed to justify them.

1 / 2