Full Breakdown
Controversy Surrounds Gary Cohen's Criticism of Matt Shaw's Absence for Charlie Kirk's Memorial
9/26/2025, 10:43:22 PM
Background of the Incident
The controversy began when New York Mets broadcaster Gary Cohen criticized Chicago Cubs rookie Matt Shaw for missing a game to attend the memorial service of conservative commentator Charlie Kirk, who was shot and killed on September 10, 2025. Shaw's absence was particularly notable as it coincided with a crucial game against the Cincinnati Reds, which the Cubs lost 1-0. Cohen remarked during a broadcast that he found it "weird" for a player to leave the team during a playoff race for any reason other than a family emergency.
Cohen's Comments and Reactions
Cohen's comments sparked significant backlash from fans and commentators alike. He stated, "I don’t want to talk about any of the politics of it, but the thought of leaving your team in the middle of a race for any reason other than a family emergency really strikes me as weird." His broadcasting partner, Todd Zeile, echoed this sentiment, calling Shaw's absence "unprecedented."
Critics quickly took to social media, with many accusing Cohen of insensitivity. Mikey McCoy, Kirk's former chief of staff, condemned Cohen's remarks, emphasizing the personal connection between Shaw and Kirk. He posted, "A month later, Charlie is gone and Matt Shaw is receiving backlash for attending his friend’s memorial. Shame on Gary Cohen."
Shaw's Defense and Team Support
In response to the criticism, Shaw defended his decision to attend the memorial, citing his strong Christian faith and the personal significance of the event. He explained, "My connection with Charlie was through our [Christian] faith... whatever backlash comes is OK." Shaw also noted that he had received support from his teammates and coaches, indicating that he had discussed his decision with them prior to attending the memorial.
Criticism of Cohen's Perspective
The backlash against Cohen intensified, with some sports commentators and fans questioning his priorities. WFAN's Gregg Giannotti criticized Cohen's stance, arguing that Shaw's decision was justified given the circumstances surrounding Kirk's death. Giannotti stated, "If he wants to go to that, he can go to that... why you’re mad, why you care, I have no idea." Other commentators pointed out that Cohen himself had taken time off for personal reasons in the past, which some viewed as hypocritical.
Official Statements & Responses
While Cohen did not issue an apology during his subsequent broadcasts, the Cubs organization confirmed that Shaw had been granted permission to attend the memorial. The incident has led to calls for accountability, with some fans suggesting a boycott of the Mets until Cohen apologizes.
Conclusion
The incident highlights the intersection of sports, personal relationships, and public commentary. As the Cubs continue their push for a playoff spot, the implications of Cohen's remarks and the public's reaction underscore the complexities athletes face in balancing professional commitments with personal values and relationships.
