Full Breakdown
New Kicker Jude McAtamney Takes the Field for Giants Against Chargers
9/28/2025, 9:35:47 PM
Activation and Replacement of Graham Gano
The New York Giants have elevated Jude McAtamney from their practice squad to serve as the starting kicker for their upcoming game against the Los Angeles Chargers at MetLife Stadium. This decision comes after veteran kicker Graham Gano was placed on injured reserve due to a groin injury sustained during pregame warmups prior to the Week 3 loss against the Kansas City Chiefs. Gano's placement on injured reserve means he will be sidelined for at least four games.
McAtamney's Journey to the NFL
Jude McAtamney, a 25-year-old native of Northern Ireland, has had a unique path to the NFL. He was signed by the Giants in 2024 as part of the International Player Pathway Program after playing college football at Chowan University and Rutgers. McAtamney previously made his NFL debut last season against the Washington Commanders, where he successfully kicked one field goal and one extra point. Despite being waived at the start of the current season, he remained on the practice squad, where he impressed coaches enough to earn this opportunity.
Competition with Younghoe Koo
The Giants recently signed veteran kicker Younghoe Koo to their practice squad, expecting him to step in for Gano. However, McAtamney outperformed Koo in a kicking competition leading up to the game. Reports indicate that Koo struggled with kickoffs during practice, which may have influenced the Giants' decision to go with McAtamney. Koo, who has an 85.8% career field goal success rate, was released by the Atlanta Falcons shortly before joining the Giants.
Official Statements & Responses
Head coach Brian Daboll expressed confidence in McAtamney's abilities, stating that the decision was made based on performance in practice. The Giants' choice to elevate McAtamney over Koo surprised many, given Koo's experience and past success. ESPN's Jordan Raanan noted that Koo's recent struggles during practice may have played a significant role in the team's decision-making process.
Criticism & Opposition
Some analysts have questioned the Giants' choice to start McAtamney over Koo, citing Koo's extensive experience in the league. Critics argue that opting for a less experienced kicker could be a risky move, especially given the Giants' current 0-3 record. However, the Giants appear to be looking for a long-term solution and may view McAtamney as a potential future asset.
What's Next
As McAtamney prepares for his second career start, he will be tasked with filling Gano's shoes for the foreseeable future. The Giants hope that his performance against the Chargers will provide a glimpse of his potential as a reliable kicker in the NFL. The outcome of this game could significantly impact McAtamney's career trajectory and the Giants' kicking situation moving forward.
