Toronto Maple Leafs Secure Anthony Stolarz with Four-Year Extension

The Toronto Maple Leafs have officially signed goaltender Anthony Stolarz to a four-year contract extension valued at $15 million, which translates to an average annual value (AAV) of $3.75 million. This deal comes as Stolarz enters the final season of a previous two-year contract he signed as a free agent in 2024. Stolarz, 31, had a standout season in 2024-25, playing 34 games and achieving a record of 21 wins, 8 losses, and 3 overtime losses. He led the league with a .926 save percentage and recorded a goals-against average (GAA) of 2.14, ranking first and third, respectively, among goaltenders with 25 or more games played.

Maple Leafs Extend Goaltender Anthony StolarzCBC NewsMaple Leafs sign Stolarz to 4-year, $15M extensionToronto Maple Leafs finalizing eye-popping deal for goalie Anthony StolarzMaple Leafs Officially Sign Anthony Stolarz To 4-Year, $15 Million Contract Extension

The timing of Stolarz's extension is significant, particularly following the announcement that fellow goaltender Joseph Woll would be taking an indefinite leave of absence for personal reasons. Stolarz's new contract solidifies his position as the Maple Leafs' primary goaltender moving forward. In addition, the team has signed veteran goaltender James Reimer to a professional tryout, providing further depth in net as they prepare for the upcoming season.

ESPN

Stolarz's extension is viewed as a strategic move for the Maple Leafs, offering both stability and financial flexibility. The $3.75 million AAV is considered a bargain compared to the market rates for starting goaltenders, which typically range from $5 million to over $10 million for elite players. This cost-effective deal allows the Maple Leafs to allocate remaining cap space to other roster needs, especially with the salary cap expected to increase by approximately $9 million next season.

Maple Leafs and Anthony Stolarz Agree to Multi-Year Extension at Bargain Price

While the extension has been largely praised, some analysts note that Stolarz's injury history—he missed significant time last season due to knee surgery and a concussion—could pose risks for the team. Critics argue that relying heavily on a goaltender with such a track record may not be prudent, especially given Woll's uncertain return timeline.

Maple Leafs Officially Sign Anthony Stolarz To 4-Year, $15 Million Contract Extension

Maple Leafs coach Craig Berube expressed confidence in Stolarz's ability to handle a larger workload, stating, "He showed us last year that he can handle the load... He's a veteran guy now." Stolarz himself conveyed enthusiasm about the extension, stating, "It's exciting for sure... I'm very excited to be a part of the Maple Leafs organization for the next few years here."

ESPN

• “It was something I wanted to wrap up before the season starts.” — Anthony Stolarz

Stolarz signs 4-year, $15 million contract with Maple Leafs

• “He’s also shown to be reliable when thrust into a full-time role.” — Analyst Commentary

Heavy

As the Maple Leafs prepare for the upcoming season, Stolarz's performance will be critical to the team's success, particularly in light of Woll's absence. The Maple Leafs will open their season on October 8 against the Montreal Canadiens, where Stolarz is expected to take on a leading role in goal.

HeavyMaple Leafs and Anthony Stolarz Agree to Multi-Year Extension at Bargain PriceESPNMaple Leafs Sign Anthony Stolarz to 4-Year Extension