Public Perception of the Supreme Court: A Record High of Conservatism

A recent Gallup poll indicates that 43% of Americans now perceive the U.S. Supreme Court as “too conservative,” marking the highest level recorded since Gallup began tracking this sentiment in 1993. This figure has risen sharply since Justice Amy Coney Barrett's appointment in October 2020, which solidified a 6-3 conservative majority. Prior to this shift, no more than 33% of respondents had ever described the Court in such terms. The poll, conducted between September 2 and 16, 2025, surveyed 1,000 adults and has a margin of error of ±4 percentage points.

United Press International (UPI)

The Supreme Court's job approval stands at 42%, a slight increase from a record low of 39% earlier this year. However, this approval rating has been consistently low, reflecting a significant decline from the 58% approval seen in 2020. Notably, the partisan divide is stark: 79% of Republicans approve of the Court's performance, while only 14% of Democrats share this view. Trust in the judicial branch remains similarly low, with only 49% of Americans expressing a fair amount of confidence in the system, a trend that has persisted for four consecutive years.

West Hawaii Today

Critics argue that the conservative majority has led to rulings that favor Republican policies and diminish civil rights. The upcoming Supreme Court term, starting October 6, 2025, is expected to address several contentious issues, including challenges to the Voting Rights Act and regulations surrounding campaign finance. Cases like Louisiana v. Callais could significantly impact minority voting rights, while others may challenge the constitutionality of campaign spending limits.

USA Today

Opponents of the Court's current trajectory express concern that its rulings are eroding democratic norms. Activists and legal experts warn that the Court's decisions could further entrench partisan gerrymandering and restrict access to the polls, particularly for marginalized communities. The perception that the Court is acting in alignment with partisan interests has fueled calls for reform and increased scrutiny of its decisions.

Ms. (Magazine)

Justice Amy Coney Barrett emphasized the importance of compromise in a recent speech, stating, "A democracy requires compromise. We can't govern ourselves if we're not willing to compromise and meet in the middle." This sentiment reflects a broader call for unity amidst growing polarization regarding the Court's role in American democracy.

Newsweek

As the Supreme Court prepares for its new term, it will confront significant cases that could redefine its relationship with the executive branch, particularly concerning President Donald Trump's policies. The Court's decisions in these upcoming cases will likely have lasting implications for the balance of power within the U.S. government and the public's trust in judicial institutions.

Common Dreams

• “We can't govern ourselves if we're not willing to compromise and meet in the middle.” — Justice Amy Coney Barrett

Newsweek

The Supreme Court's current standing reflects a complex interplay of public opinion, partisan divides, and the implications of its conservative majority, setting the stage for a pivotal term ahead.

Gallup