Controversy Over Altered Out-of-Office Emails at the Department of Education

Furloughed employees at the U.S. Department of Education reported that their out-of-office email messages were altered without their consent to include partisan language blaming Democratic senators for the federal government shutdown. This incident occurred during the first government shutdown in nearly seven years, which began on October 1, 2025, after Congress failed to agree on a funding package. Employees had initially been provided with nonpartisan templates for their automatic replies, but many discovered that these messages were changed to reflect a partisan stance while they were on furlough.

FedScoopEducation WeekInside Higher EdNBC NewsCNN

The shutdown arose from a standoff between Republicans and Democrats over funding issues, with Republicans insisting on a clean continuing resolution and Democrats demanding extensions for enhanced Affordable Care Act premium subsidies. Amid this political conflict, several federal agencies, including the Department of Education, began promoting messages that criticized Democrats for the funding impasse.

CNN

Multiple employees expressed feelings of violation and concern regarding the implications of the altered messages. One employee described the situation as "compelled speech," while another noted the distress caused by having their name associated with a message they did not endorse. The altered messages included statements such as, “Unfortunately, Democrat Senators are blocking passage of H.R. 5371 in the Senate which has led to a lapse in appropriations.” Employees feared potential violations of the Hatch Act, which prohibits federal employees from engaging in partisan political activities.

NBC News

Sheria Smith, president of the union representing Education Department staff, characterized the actions as unprecedented and expressed concern that employees could face disciplinary action for violating the Hatch Act. Richard Painter, a former chief White House ethics lawyer, indicated that the directive to alter emails could violate multiple laws, including those prohibiting political coercion in the workplace.

CNN

The Department of Education did not immediately respond to requests for comment regarding the altered messages. However, some employees noted that similar partisan language was being used across various federal agencies, including the Department of Housing and Urban Development and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, which also included messages blaming Democrats for the shutdown on their websites.

CNN

Critics of the Department of Education's actions argue that the manipulation of employees' out-of-office messages represents a disturbing politicization of federal workers. Employees who have served under multiple administrations expressed disbelief at the current level of partisanship, stating that they had never experienced such coercion in their professional roles.

CNN

Democracy Forward, a nonprofit legal organization, has announced plans to take legal action regarding the situation, indicating that the matter may escalate into a formal challenge against the Department of Education's practices. As the political landscape continues to evolve, the implications of this incident for federal employees and the enforcement of the Hatch Act remain to be seen.

Inside Higher Ed

• “None of us consented to this. And it’s written in the first-person, as if I’m the one conveying this message, and I’m not. I don’t agree with it. I don’t think it’s ethical or legal. I think it violates the Hatch Act,” — Department of Education Employee

NBC News

• “It seems like laws are dotted lines now, not solid lines.” — Department of Education Employee

NBC News

• “These out-of-office messages are yet another example of a disturbing politicizing of what should be independent federal workers.” — Sheria Smith, President of the Union

Education Week

• “It’s crazy to see the law violated on your behalf,” — Department of Education Employee

Inside Higher Ed