Baylor Edges McCallie in Historic Rivalry Showdown

On October 3, 2025, the longstanding rivalry between Baylor School and McCallie School culminated in a thrilling football game, with Baylor narrowly defeating McCallie 38-35. This matchup marked the 95th meeting between the two schools, both of which entered the game ranked in the national top 25 for the first time in history, with Baylor at No. 23 and McCallie at No. 25.

WTVC - ABC ChattanoogaThe Sporting NewsWTVC - ABC ChattanoogaHighlights, recap: No. 23 Baylor scores late to defeat No. 25 McCallie in MaxPreps Game of the WeekBaylor vs McCallie live updates: Kickoff 7.45 p.m. on NFHS NetworkKnoxville News Sentinel

The game began with McCallie taking an early lead, scoring 14 unanswered points. However, Baylor's five-star running back David Gabriel-Georges quickly turned the tide, rushing for three touchdowns and accumulating over 200 yards. His performance included impressive runs of 60, 55, and 53 yards. The game saw multiple lead changes, with McCallie briefly regaining the lead at 35-31 late in the fourth quarter, thanks to a touchdown run by senior quarterback Elliott Drapeau. Baylor's senior quarterback Briggs Cherry ultimately secured the victory with a 15-yard touchdown pass to Kaiden Dewey with just over a minute remaining.

Highlights, recap: No. 23 Baylor scores late to defeat No. 25 McCallie in MaxPreps Game of the WeekThe Sporting NewsKnoxville News SentinelWTVC - ABC ChattanoogaBaylor vs McCallie live updates: Kickoff 7.45 p.m. on NFHS Network

David Gabriel-Georges was a standout player for Baylor, showcasing his skills as a top prospect with a total of 293 rushing yards. Cherry also played a crucial role, completing 14 of 20 passes for 214 yards and contributing to the game-winning drive. For McCallie, Drapeau's leadership and offensive execution kept the game competitive, while junior running back Louis Fortier made significant contributions.

Highlights, recap: No. 23 Baylor scores late to defeat No. 25 McCallie in MaxPreps Game of the Week

The rivalry between Baylor and McCallie extends beyond the field, fostering a sense of community among alumni and current students. Tia Kemp, a McCallie alumna, noted the importance of the event in bringing people together, stating, "It's really a way for people to come together year over year." The intense competition has historically united fans and players alike, making it a significant event in Chattanooga.

WTVC - ABC Chattanooga

Following the game, Baylor's head coach praised his team's resilience and ability to perform under pressure. He emphasized the importance of this victory in the context of the rivalry, stating that it was a hard-fought win that showcased the talent on both sides. McCallie's coach acknowledged the disappointment but expressed pride in his team's effort and determination throughout the game.

WTVC - ABC Chattanooga

Despite the excitement surrounding the game, some critics pointed out the intense pressure placed on high school athletes in such high-stakes environments. Concerns were raised about the impact of such rivalries on student-athletes' mental health, particularly when the competition is as fierce as it has been historically between Baylor and McCallie.

WTVC - ABC Chattanooga

Both teams will have a week off before continuing their seasons, with Baylor maintaining an undefeated record at 6-0 and McCallie falling to 5-2. The outcome of this game may have implications for their respective standings in the upcoming state championship playoffs, as both teams are considered strong contenders in Tennessee's Division II AAA.

Knoxville News Sentinel

• “I think it's really a way for people to come together year over year, not only current students, but people who are coming back as alumni or someone like me.” — Tia Kemp, McCallie Alumna

WTVC - ABC Chattanooga