Full Breakdown
Cubs' Matthew Boyd Struggles in NLDS Game 1 Against Brewers
10/5/2025, 6:25:58 PM
Matthew Boyd's Short Start and Its Consequences
In Game 1 of the National League Division Series (NLDS) on October 4, 2025, the Chicago Cubs faced the Milwaukee Brewers, with left-hander Matthew Boyd starting on just three days' rest. This decision, made by Cubs manager Craig Counsell, quickly proved detrimental as Boyd recorded only two outs in the first inning, allowing six runs—two of which were earned—on four hits and one walk. The Cubs initially took a 1-0 lead with a leadoff home run from Michael Busch, but the Brewers responded aggressively, scoring six runs in the first inning, including three consecutive doubles from Jackson Chourio, Brice Turang, and William Contreras.
Background on Boyd's Performance
Boyd's outing marked the shortest postseason start in Cubs history since 1935, and only the fourth time a Cubs starter failed to complete an inning in playoff history. Prior to this game, Boyd had pitched well in the Wild Card Series against the San Diego Padres, allowing just one run in 4.1 innings. However, his previous struggles against the Brewers, including a 9.00 ERA in five starts during the regular season, raised concerns about his effectiveness on short rest.
Official Statements & Responses
Counsell defended the decision to start Boyd, stating, “We wouldn’t make this decision if he was coming off a six-inning start or a 90-pitch start. He had his head on it, probably when he got in the dugout.” Despite this, many fans and analysts criticized the choice, citing Boyd's heavy workload during the regular season and his lack of success against the Brewers as significant risks. Social media reactions included sentiments like, “Starting Boyd on short rest was a huge mistake,” reflecting widespread skepticism about the decision.
Criticism & Opposition
Critics highlighted that Boyd's performance was predictable given his recent innings count and previous struggles against the Brewers. Fans expressed frustration over Counsell's decision, with some suggesting that it jeopardized the Cubs' chances in the series. The error by second baseman Nico Hoerner, which extended the inning and allowed additional runs to score, further compounded the situation, leading to calls for accountability from the coaching staff.
Impact on the Series
The Cubs' bullpen managed to hold the Brewers scoreless for 4.2 innings after Boyd's departure, but the damage was done. The Brewers ultimately won the game 9-3, putting the Cubs in a challenging position as they look to rebound in the series. Boyd's performance raises questions about the Cubs' pitching strategy moving forward, especially with the potential for further adjustments in the rotation.
What's Next
As the series progresses, the Cubs will need to reassess their pitching strategy and consider the implications of Boyd's short outing. The next game is scheduled for October 6, where the Cubs will aim to even the series against the Brewers, who have gained significant momentum following their decisive victory.
