Story perspectives

VAR Error Sparks Controversy in Manchester United's Loss

10/5/2025

Summary

Story summary

Howard Webb, head of referees in England, acknowledged a VAR error in Manchester United's 3-1 loss to Brentford.
Nathan Collins should have received a red card for fouling Bryan Mbeumo in the penalty area.
The Premier League defended the yellow card, claiming Mbeumo lacked ball control, which contradicts the rules.
United's executives sought clarification from Webb, expressing frustration over officiating.
Bruno Fernandes missed the resulting penalty, affecting United's chances to equalize.

History

Historical Context

FIFA approved Video Assistant Referee (VAR) technology in 2018 after extensive trials, aiming to enhance officiating accuracy in football. Despite its introduction during the 2018 World Cup, where it had a 99.3% success rate, VAR has faced criticism for inconsistencies and confusion, particularly in the Premier League, raising ongoing debates about its effectiveness in ensuring fairness in the sport.

1 of 2

Story summary

Howard Webb, head of referees in England, acknowledged a VAR error in Manchester United's 3-1 loss to Brentford.
Nathan Collins should have received a red card for fouling Bryan Mbeumo in the penalty area.
The Premier League defended the yellow card, claiming Mbeumo lacked ball control, which contradicts the rules.
United's executives sought clarification from Webb, expressing frustration over officiating.
Bruno Fernandes missed the resulting penalty, affecting United's chances to equalize.

1 / 2