Full Breakdown
Colts Sign Michael Badgley to Replace Injured Kicker Spencer Shrader
10/8/2025, 1:34:14 AM
Injury to Spencer Shrader
The Indianapolis Colts have signed veteran kicker Michael Badgley following the season-ending injury of Spencer Shrader. During the Colts' Week 5 victory over the Las Vegas Raiders, Shrader suffered a torn ACL and MCL due to a late hit, which has left a significant gap in the team's special teams unit. Prior to his injury, Shrader was leading the NFL with 13 made field goals and had a perfect record on extra points, contributing to the Colts' impressive offensive performance, which ranks second in the league with an average of 32.6 points per game.
Michael Badgley's Return
Michael Badgley, 30, is returning to the Colts for a second stint after previously playing for the team in 2021. He had a successful season that year, converting 18 of 21 field goals and all 39 extra points. Badgley has had a varied NFL career, having played for the Los Angeles Chargers, Tennessee Titans, Chicago Bears, and Detroit Lions. He missed the entire 2024 season due to a torn hamstring but returned to action in 2023, where he made all four of his field goal attempts and 13 of 15 extra points during a brief stint with the Lions.
Experience and Performance
Badgley’s career field goal success rate stands at 82.4%, with a notable 96% success rate on extra points. His experience is seen as a crucial asset for the Colts, especially given the urgency of the situation following Shrader's injury. The Colts had worked out eight kickers before deciding to sign Badgley, who impressed during his tryout. His familiarity with the Colts' system and previous success with the team likely influenced the decision to bring him back.
Official Statements & Responses
Head coach Shane Steichen acknowledged the severity of Shrader's injury shortly after the game, indicating that it "doesn't look good." Special teams coordinator Brian Mason expressed his disappointment for Shrader, highlighting the kicker's strong start to the season and his potential for future contributions. Mason emphasized the importance of Badgley’s experience in maintaining stability within the special teams unit.
Criticism & Opposition
While Badgley brings experience, some analysts have noted concerns regarding his performance from long distances, as he has struggled with kicks over 50 yards, converting only 5 of 13 attempts in his career. This raises questions about whether he can match the reliability that Shrader had shown early in the season.
What's Next
Badgley is expected to take over kicking duties in the upcoming game against the Arizona Cardinals. The Colts will be looking to maintain their momentum and playoff aspirations as they navigate the rest of the season without Shrader. The transition will be critical for the team's success, and Badgley’s performance will be closely monitored as he steps into this pivotal role.
Verbatim Quotes
“Really, the biggest person that will make the adjustment will be the holder,” — Brian Mason, Special Teams Coordinator
“We’re just really gutted for Spencer Shrader,” — Brian Mason, Special Teams Coordinator
“The team’s decision to bring him back reflects confidence in his ability to perform under pressure and contribute to their overall success.” — Colts Insider
“He’d continued to improve, and he was really kicking at another level,” — Brian Mason, Special Teams Coordinator
