Dodgers Advance to NLCS Amid Ohtani's Struggles

The Los Angeles Dodgers secured their place in the National League Championship Series (NLCS) after defeating the Philadelphia Phillies in a dramatic Game 4 of the NL Division Series (NLDS). The Dodgers clinched the series 3-1, winning the final game 2-1 in extra innings, thanks to a costly error by Phillies pitcher Orion Kerkering. Despite the team's success, the performance of designated hitter and pitcher Shohei Ohtani has raised concerns.

Sports IllustratedSports IllustratedSports IllustratedDodgers’ Dave Roberts Announces Likely Starter for NLCS Game 1Sports IllustratedShohei Ohtani Having Offensive Slump in 2025 NLDS Ignites WILD Reactions on Social Media: “Man Hitting Worse Than Volpe”The Sporting NewsShohei Ohtani’s Playoff Woes Persist as Dodgers Suffer Game 3 Defeat to Phillies

Throughout the NLDS, Ohtani struggled significantly at the plate, finishing with a dismal 1-for-18 record, including nine strikeouts. His only hit was crucial, driving in the game-winning run in Game 2, but overall, his offensive contributions were minimal. Dodgers manager Dave Roberts noted that Ohtani's decision-making at the plate has been subpar, stating, "I just think that his plate, his decision-making hasn’t been good... he’s really not giving himself a chance to hit a mistake."

Shohei Ohtani slammed by Dave Roberts for ‘bad’ plate decisions after shocking NLDS performanceOhtani’s Playoff Woes Persist as Dodgers Crash to Phillies in Game 3Shohei Ohtani’s Struggles at the Plate: Examining Dodgers’ ConcernsSports IllustratedDodgers’ Dave Roberts Announces Likely Starter for NLCS Game 1Shohei Ohtani Having Offensive Slump in 2025 NLDS Ignites WILD Reactions on Social Media: “Man Hitting Worse Than Volpe”Shohei Ohtani’s Playoff Woes Persist as Dodgers Suffer Game 3 Defeat to PhilliesShohei aims to get going offensively as Dodgers mull NLCS pitching plan

While Ohtani's batting was underwhelming, he excelled as a pitcher. In his postseason debut during Game 1 of the NLDS, he pitched six innings, striking out nine batters and allowing three earned runs. This dual-threat capability remains a vital asset for the Dodgers as they prepare for the NLCS, where Ohtani is expected to start Game 1.

Dodgers’ Dave Roberts Announces Likely Starter for NLCS Game 1Sports IllustratedShohei Ohtani’s Playoff Woes Persist as Dodgers Suffer Game 3 Defeat to PhilliesShohei Ohtani’s Struggles at the Plate: Examining Dodgers’ ConcernsOhtani’s Playoff Woes Persist as Dodgers Crash to Phillies in Game 3Shohei Ohtani slammed by Dave Roberts for ‘bad’ plate decisions after shocking NLDS performanceNewsweekSports Illustrated

Dodgers catcher Will Smith expressed optimism about Ohtani's potential for a breakout performance in the upcoming series, suggesting that "there's another gear" for him to reach. The Dodgers will face either the Chicago Cubs or Milwaukee Brewers in the NLCS, with Ohtani's past success against both teams offering hope for improved performance.

Sports IllustratedThe Sporting NewsShohei Ohtani’s Struggles at the Plate: Examining Dodgers’ ConcernsDodgers’ Dave Roberts Announces Likely Starter for NLCS Game 1Shohei Ohtani slammed by Dave Roberts for ‘bad’ plate decisions after shocking NLDS performanceShohei Ohtani’s Playoff Woes Persist as Dodgers Suffer Game 3 Defeat to PhilliesNewsweekOhtani’s Playoff Woes Persist as Dodgers Crash to Phillies in Game 3

The decision-making of Phillies manager Rob Thomson has also come under scrutiny, particularly his choice to intentionally walk Ohtani during a critical moment in Game 4. Many analysts criticized this strategy, especially given Ohtani's struggles in the series. Mookie Betts, who followed Ohtani in the batting order, capitalized on the situation by drawing a walk that tied the game.

Mookie Betts hard-earned walk that helped clinch a spot in the NLCS

As the Dodgers prepare for the NLCS, the spotlight will be on Ohtani to regain his form at the plate. His postseason batting average has dropped to .160, raising questions about his ability to contribute offensively. The Dodgers' success in the upcoming series may hinge on Ohtani's performance, both as a hitter and a pitcher.

Shohei Ohtani’s Struggles at the Plate: Examining Dodgers’ ConcernsSports IllustratedShohei Ohtani slammed by Dave Roberts for ‘bad’ plate decisions after shocking NLDS performanceNewsweekDodgers’ Dave Roberts Announces Likely Starter for NLCS Game 1Ohtani’s Playoff Woes Persist as Dodgers Crash to Phillies in Game 3Shohei Ohtani’s Playoff Woes Persist as Dodgers Suffer Game 3 Defeat to PhilliesFanSided

Dodgers manager Dave Roberts emphasized the need for Ohtani to improve his swing decisions and regain focus. "I think the lefties are part of it... but the swing decisions are just not where they need to be right now," Roberts stated. This assessment highlights the urgency for Ohtani to adjust as the Dodgers aim for back-to-back World Series titles.

Shohei Ohtani slammed by Dave Roberts for ‘bad’ plate decisions after shocking NLDS performance

• “I just think that his plate, his decision-making hasn’t been good,” — Dave Roberts, Dodgers Manager

Shohei Ohtani slammed by Dave Roberts for ‘bad’ plate decisions after shocking NLDS performance

• “I think there's another gear,” — Will Smith, Dodgers Catcher

Sports Illustrated

• “He can explode at any time; he’s that great of a hitter.” — Rob Thomson, Phillies Manager

Ohtani’s Playoff Woes Persist as Dodgers Crash to Phillies in Game 3

As the Dodgers move forward, the performance of Shohei Ohtani will be pivotal in determining their success in the NLCS and beyond.

Sports Illustrated