Full Breakdown
Paul Scholes Names Sandro Tonali as Premier League's Best Midfielder
10/9/2025, 5:33:46 PM
Overview of the Debate
The discussion surrounding the best midfielder in the Premier League has intensified following former Manchester United star Paul Scholes' declaration that Newcastle United's Sandro Tonali is currently the top player in that position. This assertion has sparked contrasting opinions among football pundits and fans alike, particularly in light of Sky Sports pundit Gary Neville's endorsement of Chelsea's Moises Caicedo as the best midfielder after his standout performance against Liverpool.
Scholes' Perspective on Tonali
During an episode of "The Overlap," Scholes expressed his admiration for Tonali, stating, “I’d probably choose Tonali at this point [as the best midfielder in the Premier League]. Over Declan Rice, yeah. Tonali is better than Rice.” Scholes emphasized Tonali's all-around capabilities, contrasting him with Caicedo, whom he does not consider an "all-round midfielder." He noted that while Caicedo has shown brilliance, particularly in breaking up play, he prefers midfielders who can control the game and contribute more consistently in terms of goals.
Responses from Other Pundits
The debate has seen various opinions emerge. Gary Neville praised Caicedo, calling him “the best player on the pitch” in Chelsea's recent match against Liverpool. He highlighted Caicedo's impact, stating, “If Liverpool had him, they would have won; he was that good.” In contrast, other pundits have rallied behind Declan Rice, with some arguing that he has evolved into a more complete midfielder capable of contributing defensively and offensively.
Criticism of Scholes' Choice
While Scholes' choice of Tonali has garnered support, it has also faced criticism. Some fans and pundits argue that Rice's consistency and contributions to Arsenal make him a stronger candidate. Scholes himself acknowledged Rice's abilities but critiqued him for taking “too many touches of the ball” and trying to be “too elegant” in his play. This sentiment reflects a broader debate about the qualities that define an elite midfielder.
Statistical Comparisons
Statistical analysis further complicates the debate. This season, Tonali has one goal contribution, while both Caicedo and Rice have three. In terms of possession won, Tonali ranks in the 64th percentile, higher than Rice's 23rd but lower than Caicedo's 79th. Rice also surpasses Tonali in key passes and progressive passes, indicating a more impactful role in his team's attacking play.
Conclusion
The discourse surrounding the best midfielder in the Premier League is multifaceted, with Scholes' endorsement of Sandro Tonali igniting a spirited debate. While opinions vary, the contrasting views on Tonali, Rice, and Caicedo highlight the subjective nature of evaluating midfield talent in football. As the season progresses, performances will continue to shape this ongoing conversation.
Verbatim Quotes
- “I’d probably choose Tonali at this point [as the best midfielder in the Premier League]. Over Declan Rice, yeah. Tonali is better than Rice.” — Paul Scholes, Former Manchester United Midfielder
- “He was the best player on the pitch by a mile, and if Liverpool had him, they would have won; he was that good.” — Gary Neville, Sky Sports Pundit
- “Sometimes he takes a few too many touches of the ball and tries to look a bit more stylish than necessary.” — Paul Scholes on Declan Rice
