Criticism Mounts Against Preseason AP Top 25 Poll in 2025 College Football Season

The 2025 Associated Press (AP) Preseason Top 25 poll has faced significant criticism as several teams, including the top-ranked Texas Longhorns and the second-ranked Penn State Nittany Lions, have fallen out of the rankings after disappointing performances. This season's early results have led analysts and fans to question the relevance and accuracy of preseason rankings, which are often based on hype, recruiting, and brand reputation rather than actual performance on the field.

OutKickPreseason AP Poll’s Credibility Crumbles After Week 6The Sporting NewsJoel Klatt ready to scrap preseason polls: ‘They’ve misled the public’Fairmont SentinelSports Illustrated

The Texas Longhorns entered the season as the No. 1 team, buoyed by high expectations surrounding quarterback Arch Manning and a substantial NIL budget. However, Texas has struggled, currently holding a 3-2 record after losses to unranked opponents, including a recent defeat against the Florida Gators. Similarly, Penn State, ranked No. 2, has also dropped out of the poll following a shocking loss to the UCLA Bruins, marking a significant decline from their previous season's near championship appearance.

Fairmont Sentinel

Clemson, starting the season at No. 4, has also faced challenges, beginning the year with a 1-3 record, including losses to LSU and Georgia Tech. Notre Dame and Kansas State have similarly seen their preseason rankings evaporate due to underwhelming performances.

OutKick

Critics argue that the preseason AP Poll creates misleading narratives that can persist throughout the season, influencing perceptions and decisions made by the College Football Playoff (CFP) committee. Joel Klatt, a prominent college football analyst, has voiced strong opposition to the existence of preseason polls, stating, “I would be totally fine with that. I’ve thought they’ve misled the college football public for a long time.” He emphasizes that the transfer portal has made predicting team performance increasingly difficult, as rosters can change dramatically from one season to the next.

Joel Klatt ready to scrap preseason polls: ‘They’ve misled the public’

Big 12 Commissioner Brett Yormark has echoed these sentiments, eliminating his conference's preseason poll, arguing that it unfairly impacts teams before they have played a game. Several coaches from the Big Ten have also expressed concerns about the narratives created by preseason rankings.

Joel Klatt ready to scrap preseason polls: ‘They’ve misled the public’

The AP Poll's credibility has been called into question, with many analysts and fans advocating for its removal. Critics highlight that the rankings often reward teams based on potential rather than actual performance, leading to inflated expectations. The argument for maintaining the poll centers on its role in generating discussion among fans and media, but many believe this is insufficient justification for its continued existence.

Preseason AP Poll’s Credibility Crumbles After Week 6

While the AP Poll has faced backlash, some argue that it still serves a purpose in providing a framework for discussions about team performance. However, the overwhelming sentiment among critics is that the preseason rankings are increasingly irrelevant in the context of the current college football landscape, particularly with the rise of the transfer portal.

Preseason AP Poll’s Credibility Crumbles After Week 6

As the 2025 season progresses, the debate over the necessity of preseason polls continues. With top teams like Texas and Penn State now unranked, the call for reform or elimination of the AP Preseason Poll is gaining traction. The ongoing discussions highlight the need for a reevaluation of how college football teams are assessed and ranked, especially in an era marked by rapid changes in player rosters and team dynamics.

OutKick