Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

PEN America vs. Moms For Liberty: Clash Over Book Bans

10/10/2025

34 3 Full Breakdown

Summary

Story summary

PEN America and Moms For Liberty clash over book bans, advocating contrasting approaches to access.
PEN America tracks book bans since 2021 and pursues restrictions through lawsuits.
Definitions differ: PEN America calls removals censorship; Moms For Liberty calls stewardship.
State laws and politics foster fear among educators, increasing school censorship.

History

Historical Context

The 1982 Supreme Court case Board of Education v. Pico affirmed students' rights to access diverse literature, ruling that school boards cannot remove books solely based on disapproval of their ideas. Since 2021, over 1,500 book bans have emerged, driven by groups like Moms For Liberty, reflecting ongoing tensions between censorship and educational freedom, reminiscent of historical debates over First Amendment rights.

1 of 2

Story summary

PEN America and Moms For Liberty clash over book bans, advocating contrasting approaches to access.
PEN America tracks book bans since 2021 and pursues restrictions through lawsuits.
Definitions differ: PEN America calls removals censorship; Moms For Liberty calls stewardship.
State laws and politics foster fear among educators, increasing school censorship.

1 / 2