Story perspectives

SNP Majority Sparks Debate on Second Independence Referendum

10/16/2025

34 7

Summary

Story summary

John Swinney (Scottish National Party, SNP) asserts that the SNP's Holyrood majority sets a precedent for a second independence referendum.
Legal experts argue that the 2014 referendum agreement does not support a second vote.
Joanna Cherry KC labeled Swinney's claim "back of the envelope nonsense."
Professor James Mitchell says the UK operates under a "political constitution."
The Scottish Greens warn that focusing on an SNP majority could alienate independence supporters.

1 of 1

Story summary

John Swinney (Scottish National Party, SNP) asserts that the SNP's Holyrood majority sets a precedent for a second independence referendum.
Legal experts argue that the 2014 referendum agreement does not support a second vote.
Joanna Cherry KC labeled Swinney's claim "back of the envelope nonsense."
Professor James Mitchell says the UK operates under a "political constitution."
The Scottish Greens warn that focusing on an SNP majority could alienate independence supporters.