Full Breakdown
Mariners Adjust Pitching Strategy Ahead of Game 5 in ALCS
10/17/2025, 7:34:42 AM
Bryce Miller to Start Game 5, Bryan Woo Available in Relief
The Seattle Mariners have announced that Bryce Miller will start Game 5 of the American League Championship Series (ALCS) against the Toronto Blue Jays, while All-Star pitcher Bryan Woo will be available out of the bullpen. This decision comes after Woo, who has been sidelined since September 19 due to right pectoral inflammation, was initially considered for the starting role. Mariners manager Dan Wilson confirmed the change, emphasizing the need for Woo to ease back into competition after a lengthy absence.
Miller, who has a postseason ERA of 2.61, previously pitched six innings of one-run ball in Game 1 against the Blue Jays, contributing to Seattle's early series lead. In contrast, Woo, who posted a 15-7 record with a 2.94 ERA during the regular season, has not pitched in a game for nearly a month. Wilson noted that Woo's transition to a relief role is a unique situation, as he has primarily been a starter throughout his career.
Background on Bryan Woo's Injury and Recovery
Bryan Woo's injury has been a significant concern for the Mariners. After leaving a game against the Houston Astros early, he was not placed on the injured list, as the team believed he could recover without a lengthy absence. However, his recovery took longer than expected, leading to his exclusion from the ALDS roster. Woo's return to the mound is seen as a positive development, even if it is in a limited capacity. He has expressed eagerness to contribute, stating, “I’m just trying to find any way I can to help the team.”
Criticism & Opposition: Concerns Over Woo's Role
Despite the optimism surrounding Woo's return, there are concerns about his readiness to pitch effectively after such a long layoff. Former Mariners reliever Ryan Rowland-Smith highlighted the challenges of transitioning from a starter to a reliever, particularly in high-stakes postseason games. He noted that Woo's injury was not severe enough to warrant a complete shutdown, which complicates his return to game speed. Rowland-Smith remarked, “He hasn’t gotten to game speed... If you were to have him come out of the bullpen, it may serve him well to say, ‘Look, Bryan, just have at it.’”
Official Statements & Responses
Manager Dan Wilson addressed the decision to start Miller over Woo, stating, “Bryan’s going to be available out of the pen, and I think that’s the plan here going forward.” He acknowledged the unique nature of the postseason, where players are often asked to perform in unfamiliar roles. Wilson expressed confidence in both pitchers, noting that Woo has a wealth of experience and support from teammates who have successfully transitioned to relief roles.
What's Next: Game 5 and Series Outlook
Game 5 is set for Friday at 3:08 p.m. PT at T-Mobile Park, with the Mariners leading the series 2-1. The Blue Jays will counter with Kevin Gausman, who has had a solid postseason thus far. The outcome of this pivotal game could determine whether the Mariners advance to the World Series for the first time in franchise history. As the series progresses, the effectiveness of both Miller and Woo will be crucial for Seattle's chances of clinching the AL pennant.
