Story perspectives

J.J. Watt Slams PFF Grades as 'Completely Made Up'

10/17/2025

28 6

Summary

Story summary

J.J. Watt, three-time NFL Defensive Player of the Year, criticized Pro Football Focus for its player grading on The Pat McAfee Show.
He labeled PFF grades as "completely made up" and misleading, while acknowledging useful analytical tools.
Watt said accurate grading requires understanding a player's assignments, which he says PFF's method often lacks.
He raised concerns about individuals without professional backgrounds contributing to PFF's grades and noted Chris Long's agreement.

1 of 1

Story summary

J.J. Watt, three-time NFL Defensive Player of the Year, criticized Pro Football Focus for its player grading on The Pat McAfee Show.
He labeled PFF grades as "completely made up" and misleading, while acknowledging useful analytical tools.
Watt said accurate grading requires understanding a player's assignments, which he says PFF's method often lacks.
He raised concerns about individuals without professional backgrounds contributing to PFF's grades and noted Chris Long's agreement.