New York Giants Waive Kicker Jude McAtamney After Costly Misses

The New York Giants have waived kicker Jude McAtamney following a disappointing performance in their 33-32 loss to the Denver Broncos on October 19, 2025. McAtamney missed two crucial extra point attempts during the game, marking a significant factor in the team's defeat. His first miss occurred in the second quarter, contributing to a missed opportunity for a two-point conversion later in the game. The second miss, with just 37 seconds remaining, left the Giants with a two-point lead, allowing the Broncos to drive down the field and secure a game-winning field goal from Wil Lutz as time expired.

Big News NetworkAM New YorkFox News (website)Bleacher ReportDaily Mail

McAtamney's performance was particularly notable as he became the first kicker in 40 years to miss two unblocked extra points in a one-point loss. This statistic underscores the rarity and severity of his mistakes, which have drawn significant scrutiny from fans and analysts alike. The Giants had initially led the game 19-0 before allowing the Broncos to score 33 points in the fourth quarter, highlighting broader issues within the team's defense and overall game management.

AM New York

After the game, McAtamney took full responsibility for his performance, stating, “It’s on me. I missed vital points at vital times today. I’m not gonna shy away from that.” Giants head coach Brian Daboll acknowledged the collective nature of the loss, emphasizing that it was not solely McAtamney's fault, saying, “It doesn’t come down to one play; it was a number of them.” This sentiment reflects the complexity of the game, where multiple factors contributed to the outcome.

Derry’s McAtamney Takes Responsibility for New York Giants Loss ‘I’ve Got to Make the Kicks’

Despite McAtamney's accountability, criticism has emerged regarding the decision to start him over veteran kicker Younghoe Koo, who has a more established track record. Many analysts questioned the Giants' choice to elevate McAtamney from the practice squad, especially given his inconsistent performance, which included missing three extra points in his last two games. The Giants' overall kicking struggles have been highlighted, as they currently hold the worst extra-point percentage in the NFL.

NBC SportsDerry’s McAtamney Takes Responsibility for New York Giants Loss ‘I’ve Got to Make the Kicks’Staten Island AdvanceAM New YorkGiants cut Jude McAtamney after costly misses, uncertainty looms over kicker situation

Following McAtamney's release, the Giants are expected to either activate Graham Gano from injured reserve or promote Younghoe Koo from the practice squad for their upcoming game against the Philadelphia Eagles. Gano, who has been sidelined due to a groin injury, is a proven kicker with a career field goal percentage of 83.9%. The Giants are looking for stability in their kicking game as they aim to improve their current record of 2-5.

HeavyGiants cut Jude McAtamney after costly misses, uncertainty looms over kicker situationFox News (website)Bleacher ReportESPN

• “I’ve got to make the kicks.” — Jude McAtamney, Kicker

Derry’s McAtamney Takes Responsibility for New York Giants Loss ‘I’ve Got to Make the Kicks’

• “It’s not one play, it’s not one position. It’s collective.” — Brian Daboll, Head Coach

Derry’s McAtamney Takes Responsibility for New York Giants Loss ‘I’ve Got to Make the Kicks’

• “I missed vital points at vital times today.” — Jude McAtamney, Kicker

RTE (Radio Television of Ireland)

The Giants' decision to part ways with McAtamney reflects the high stakes and pressures faced by players in the NFL, particularly in pivotal moments that can define a team's season.

Derry’s McAtamney Takes Responsibility for New York Giants Loss ‘I’ve Got to Make the Kicks’