Story perspectives

Scottish Deposit Scheme Faces Court Criticism, Business Backlash

10/25/2025

Summary

Story summary

The Scottish Government's handling of the deposit return scheme faced court criticism, with Lord Alister Jack calling it 'utterly irresponsible' and citing transparency gaps.
More than 1,000 businesses warned of harm, including French wine producers threatening to cease sales in Scotland.
Circularity Scotland's chief executive said the scheme's liabilities were not fully known.
Court proceedings continue as Biffa Waste Services seeks £166 million in damages for losses from the project.

History

Historical Context

Scotland's Deposit Return Scheme (DRS), proposed in 2017, aimed to enhance recycling and reduce litter. Inspired by Germany's successful 2012 initiative, which achieved a 98% return rate, the Scottish scheme faced delays and criticism from retailers. As of 2021, businesses expressed concerns over potential sales losses, while Biffa Waste Services claimed £166 million in damages, highlighting the financial stakes involved.

1 of 2

Story summary

The Scottish Government's handling of the deposit return scheme faced court criticism, with Lord Alister Jack calling it 'utterly irresponsible' and citing transparency gaps.
More than 1,000 businesses warned of harm, including French wine producers threatening to cease sales in Scotland.
Circularity Scotland's chief executive said the scheme's liabilities were not fully known.
Court proceedings continue as Biffa Waste Services seeks £166 million in damages for losses from the project.

1 / 2