Full Breakdown
Kicking Controversy: Brandon McManus vs. Lucas Havrisik in Green Bay
10/27/2025, 12:37:09 PM
McManus Struggles in Return from Injury
Brandon McManus' return to the Green Bay Packers lineup on October 26 against the Pittsburgh Steelers was marked by significant challenges. After missing two games due to a quad injury, McManus missed both field goals he attempted in the first half, including a 57-yarder and a 44-yarder, contributing to the Packers trailing 16-7 at halftime. His performance raised questions about his fitness and decision-making, especially given the success of backup kicker Lucas Havrisik, who had filled in admirably during McManus' absence.
Havrisik's Impressive Performance
Lucas Havrisik, who joined the Packers earlier in October, had been perfect in his two games as a starter, converting all four field goals and six extra points, including a franchise-record 61-yard field goal against the Arizona Cardinals. His performance not only showcased his potential but also created a dilemma for the Packers as they approached the trade deadline on November 4. Despite Havrisik's success, the Packers opted to retain both kickers on the roster, indicating a strategic decision to hedge their bets on McManus' health.
Official Statements & Responses
The Packers' decision to stick with McManus over Havrisik drew criticism from fans and media alike. Many questioned the rationale behind starting McManus, especially after his missed opportunities led to a nine-point swing in the game. Critics pointed out that McManus had already missed four field goals this season, raising concerns about his reliability. The Packers, however, seemed committed to McManus, who had previously signed a three-year contract extension after a successful 2024 season.
Criticism & Opposition
The decision to start McManus was met with backlash, particularly after his performance against the Steelers. Fans expressed frustration on social media, with some commentators suggesting that the Packers should have continued with Havrisik, who had proven to be a reliable option. The criticism intensified given McManus' history of missed kicks this season, including a crucial miss in a previous game against the Cleveland Browns.
What's Next for the Packers?
As the Packers navigate the remainder of the season, the future of their kicking situation remains uncertain. With the trade deadline approaching, the team may explore options to trade McManus, which could provide salary cap relief. Meanwhile, Havrisik's performance has positioned him as a potential starting kicker for other teams, should the Packers decide to part ways with McManus.
Verbatim Quotes
- “Had 34 seconds to get into field-goal range. Completed all 3 of his passes for 36 yards … and Brandon McManus pushes the 44-yard field goal wide left. Have to question not playing Lucas Havrisik tonight.” — Ryan Wood, USA Today
- “and Brandon McManus pushes the 44-yard field goal wide left.” — Critic on social media
- “The Packers never wanted to go away from McManus.” — Source on team strategy
The Packers' kicking situation continues to evolve, with McManus' performance under scrutiny and Havrisik's future potentially brightening as the team assesses its options moving forward.
