Full Breakdown
Miami Dolphins' Quarterback Decisions: A Focus on Quinn Ewers
10/27/2025, 1:13:46 PM
Current Quarterback Situation
The Miami Dolphins have made significant decisions regarding their quarterback lineup during the 2025 NFL season. Tua Tagovailoa remains the starting quarterback, but the backup position has seen a shift between Zach Wilson and rookie Quinn Ewers. As of the latest game against the Atlanta Falcons, Wilson was named the primary backup, relegating Ewers to the emergency third quarterback role. This decision comes despite Ewers' recent promotion to backup after a brief appearance in the previous game against the Cleveland Browns, where he completed 5 of 8 passes for 53 yards.
Performance and Development of Young Players
The Dolphins have focused on developing young talent this season, starting several rookies, including Kenneth Grant, Jonah Savaiinaea, and Jordan Phillips. Despite a challenging 1-6 record, the team has remained committed to these players. Critics argue that Ewers, who was drafted in the seventh round, should be given more playing time over Wilson, who has struggled throughout his career. Ewers' performance in limited action has drawn comparisons to Wilson, who has been criticized for his accuracy and decision-making.
Official Statements & Responses
Dolphins head coach Mike McDaniel has indicated that the decision to switch between Wilson and Ewers is based on weekly practice performance and matchups. However, the rationale behind Ewers' demotion after showing potential remains unclear. Observers have noted that if Tagovailoa were to be sidelined due to injury, it would be more beneficial for the team to invest in Ewers' development rather than relying on Wilson, who is not expected to be re-signed after this season.
Criticism & Opposition
Critics of the Dolphins' decision-making argue that the team is missing an opportunity to evaluate Ewers' potential as a future starter. The comparison to Brock Purdy, who emerged as a successful quarterback for the San Francisco 49ers after being thrust into action, highlights the risks of not giving Ewers a chance to play. Detractors question why Ewers is treated differently from other rookies who have been given opportunities despite their struggles.
Conflicting Reports & Gaps
There is a discrepancy in the Dolphins' approach to their quarterback depth chart. While Ewers was promoted to backup last week, he was quickly demoted again, raising questions about the team's evaluation process. Additionally, Tagovailoa's health was a concern leading up to the game against the Falcons, as he dealt with an illness that resulted in a swollen eye. Despite this, he performed well, throwing four touchdowns in a 34-10 victory.
What's Next
As the Dolphins continue their season, the focus will remain on how they manage their quarterback situation. With Tagovailoa's health and Wilson's inconsistent performance, the team may need to reconsider their approach to Ewers, especially if they aim to build for the future. The upcoming games will be critical in determining whether the Dolphins will give Ewers more opportunities to showcase his abilities.
