Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

VAR Controversy: Diallo's Penalty Denial Sparks Debate

10/28/2025

33 5 Full Breakdown

Summary

Story summary

Amad Diallo of Manchester United was denied a penalty against Brighton.
VAR confirmed Maxim De Cuyper's slight touch on the ball.
Dermot Gallagher, a former referee, supported the referee's decision.
Jay Bothroyd, a former referee, disagreed, arguing the contact impeded Amad's ability to play the ball.
This discussion reflects ongoing tensions in Premier League refereeing.

History

Historical Context

The Premier League adopted Video Assistant Referee (VAR) technology in 2019 to enhance officiating accuracy, following its successful implementation in the 2018 World Cup. Despite a reported 98% accuracy rate, VAR has faced criticism for inconsistencies and subjective decision-making, as seen in contentious incidents like Amad Diallo's recent case, highlighting ongoing debates about its effectiveness in maintaining fairness in football.

1 of 2

Story summary

Amad Diallo of Manchester United was denied a penalty against Brighton.
VAR confirmed Maxim De Cuyper's slight touch on the ball.
Dermot Gallagher, a former referee, supported the referee's decision.
Jay Bothroyd, a former referee, disagreed, arguing the contact impeded Amad's ability to play the ball.
This discussion reflects ongoing tensions in Premier League refereeing.

1 / 2