Story perspectives

Judge Slams DOJ's Handling of Comey Case Evidence

11/6/2025

27 6

Summary

Story summary

Judge William Fitzpatrick criticized the Justice Department's evidence handling in the criminal case against former FBI Director James Comey.
During a hearing, he highlighted an "indict first, investigate later" approach and the prosecution's failure to provide communications from Comey's confidant, Daniel Richman.
Comey, charged with lying to Congress, pleaded not guilty, and the judge ordered prosecutors to disclose all relevant materials by Thursday.
Concerns have been raised by current and former prosecutors about potential political motivations influenced by former President Trump.

1 of 1

Story summary

Judge William Fitzpatrick criticized the Justice Department's evidence handling in the criminal case against former FBI Director James Comey.
During a hearing, he highlighted an "indict first, investigate later" approach and the prosecution's failure to provide communications from Comey's confidant, Daniel Richman.
Comey, charged with lying to Congress, pleaded not guilty, and the judge ordered prosecutors to disclose all relevant materials by Thursday.
Concerns have been raised by current and former prosecutors about potential political motivations influenced by former President Trump.