Story perspectives

Herbstreit Defends College Football Playoff Rankings Amid Criticism

11/8/2025

24 4

Summary

Story summary

Kirk Herbstreit defended the College Football Playoff selection committee after the initial rankings.
He acknowledged there will never be a consensus on team rankings, inviting criticism.
Herbstreit emphasized that committee members bring diverse perspectives to decisions.
He said the initial rankings should not be scrutinized, as changes are expected in coming weeks.
He found nothing egregious in the rankings and recognized the difficulty of satisfying all college football fans.

1 of 1

Story summary

Kirk Herbstreit defended the College Football Playoff selection committee after the initial rankings.
He acknowledged there will never be a consensus on team rankings, inviting criticism.
Herbstreit emphasized that committee members bring diverse perspectives to decisions.
He said the initial rankings should not be scrutinized, as changes are expected in coming weeks.
He found nothing egregious in the rankings and recognized the difficulty of satisfying all college football fans.