Rams' Kicking Situation: Harrison Mevis vs. Joshua Karty

The Los Angeles Rams have activated kicker Harrison Mevis from their practice squad for their Week 11 matchup against the Seattle Seahawks. Mevis, who made all six of his extra-point attempts in his NFL debut against the San Francisco 49ers, is set to continue as the team's kicker. Head coach Sean McVay has expressed confidence in Mevis, stating, “He did a good job going six-for-six on the extra points. I was pleased with that.” However, McVay has not fully committed to Mevis as the long-term solution, indicating ongoing support for Joshua Karty, who was benched after a series of inconsistent performances.

Rams Make Final Roster Move Before Taking on SeahawksRams only have 2 more games to make a definitive decision at kickerHeavyRams make kicker roster move for Seahawks clashRams elevate K Harrison Mevis for second consecutive week

Harrison Mevis, an undrafted free agent from Missouri, was signed to the Rams' practice squad earlier this month. He previously played for the Birmingham Stallions in the UFL, where he achieved a notable 20-of-21 on field goals. In contrast, Joshua Karty, a sixth-round draft pick in 2024, has struggled, converting only 10 of 15 field goals and missing three of 26 extra-point attempts in the first half of the season. The Rams' decision to elevate Mevis reflects their need for stability in the kicking game as they pursue a playoff position.

Heavy

The Rams face a critical decision regarding their kicking situation after Week 12. Mevis can only be elevated from the practice squad a maximum of three times during the season, meaning he must be signed to the active roster if he is to continue kicking beyond this point. McVay has indicated that the team will evaluate Mevis's performance over the next two weeks before making a final decision. If Mevis proves reliable, the Rams may consider cutting Karty and re-signing him to the practice squad, although they are wary of losing him to another team.

Rams only have 2 more games to make a definitive decision at kickerHeavyRams Make Final Roster Move Before Taking on SeahawksRams elevate K Harrison Mevis for second consecutive week

Despite the Rams' current strategy, some analysts argue that maintaining two kickers on the roster is inefficient. Critics suggest that the Rams should streamline their roster by committing to one kicker, as having two can lead to unnecessary complications and roster limitations. The Rams' approach mirrors that of the Green Bay Packers, who have also kept two kickers on their roster, a strategy that some believe could hinder overall team performance.

Rams elevate K Harrison Mevis for second consecutive week

Sean McVay has reiterated his belief in Karty's potential, stating, “I have a lot of belief in Josh Karty. I think he's a guy that's going to have an incredibly bright future.” This sentiment reflects the Rams' cautious approach as they navigate their kicking dilemma, balancing immediate performance needs with long-term development.

Rams only have 2 more games to make a definitive decision at kicker

• “I have a lot of belief in Josh Karty,” — Sean McVay, Head Coach

Rams only have 2 more games to make a definitive decision at kicker

• “Dude is a weapon.” — UStadium, on Harrison Mevis

Heavy

• “I think the future is really bright for him and he'll be on the roster.” — Sean McVay, on Joshua Karty

Rams only have 2 more games to make a definitive decision at kicker

As the Rams prepare for their critical matchup against the Seahawks, the performance of Harrison Mevis will be closely monitored, with implications for both his future and that of Joshua Karty in the team's kicking strategy.

Rams only have 2 more games to make a definitive decision at kicker