Full Breakdown
Week 11 Fantasy Football Tight End Decisions: Kyle Pitts vs. Theo Johnson
11/17/2025, 1:44:52 AM
Overview of the Matchup
As fantasy football managers prepare for Week 11, the decision between starting Atlanta Falcons tight end Kyle Pitts and New York Giants tight end Theo Johnson has emerged as a critical one. Both players present unique advantages and challenges based on their recent performances and upcoming matchups.
Kyle Pitts: Performance and Prospects
Kyle Pitts has had a mixed season, currently ranking as the TE15 in fantasy points per game. He has caught 45 of 59 targets for 420 yards and one touchdown, averaging 46.7 receiving yards per game. Pitts has a 19.8% target share and is a key first-read option on nearly 18% of dropbacks. His upcoming matchup against the Carolina Panthers, who have allowed the seventh-most fantasy points to tight ends, presents a favorable opportunity. However, Pitts has struggled with consistency, having only scored 11 touchdowns in his five-year career, which limits his upside. In their previous encounter this season, he managed just 39 yards without a touchdown against the Panthers.
Theo Johnson: Rising Star Amidst Challenges
Theo Johnson has emerged as a significant target for the Giants, particularly with injuries depleting their receiving corps. He has averaged 41.3 receiving yards per game and has scored five touchdowns this season. Johnson's recent performance includes a standout game where he caught seven of eight targets for 75 yards. This week, he will be catching passes from Jameis Winston, who is known for his aggressive passing style, potentially increasing Johnson's scoring opportunities. However, Johnson faces a tougher matchup against the Green Bay Packers, who allow the 12th-most fantasy points to tight ends.
Comparative Analysis
While Pitts has a more stable role in a conservative Falcons offense, Johnson's recent spike in targets and touchdown potential makes him an appealing option. The Giants' limited receiving options could lead to increased volume for Johnson, while Pitts' historical inconsistency raises concerns about his reliability.
Verdict: Start Theo Johnson
Given the current circumstances, the recommendation is to start Theo Johnson over Kyle Pitts. Johnson's higher touchdown upside and increased target share in a depleted Giants offense outweigh the risks associated with his matchup. Conversely, Pitts, despite a favorable matchup, has shown a pattern of disappointing performances that make him a less reliable choice.
Official Statements & Responses
Kyle Pitts acknowledged the need for improvement, stating, “I feel like I left a play out there on the field. It sucks losing.” His coach, Raheem Morris, expressed confidence in Pitts but emphasized the need for him to contribute more to the offense.
Conclusion
As fantasy managers finalize their lineups for Week 11, the choice between Kyle Pitts and Theo Johnson hinges on the balance of risk and reward. With Johnson's recent form and potential for increased involvement, he stands out as the preferable option for this week’s fantasy lineup.
