Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

Authors Disqualified from Awards Over AI-Designed Covers

11/18/2025

46 6

Summary

Story summary

New Zealand authors Elizabeth Smither and Stephanie Johnson were disqualified from the Ockham book awards over AI-generated cover designs.
Quentin Wilson, the publisher, expressed distress and urged judgments based on writing quality rather than packaging.
Johnson said she was surprised by guidelines that include cover design in judging criteria.
Critics argue the exclusion undermines the authors’ literary achievements.

1 of 1

Story summary

New Zealand authors Elizabeth Smither and Stephanie Johnson were disqualified from the Ockham book awards over AI-generated cover designs.
Quentin Wilson, the publisher, expressed distress and urged judgments based on writing quality rather than packaging.
Johnson said she was surprised by guidelines that include cover design in judging criteria.
Critics argue the exclusion undermines the authors’ literary achievements.