Full Breakdown
San Francisco 49ers Sign Matt Gay as Temporary Replacement for Eddy Piñeiro
11/20/2025, 4:21:51 PM
Kicker Replacement Amid Injury Concerns
The San Francisco 49ers have signed kicker Matt Gay to their practice squad as a temporary replacement for Eddy Piñeiro, who is sidelined due to a Grade 1 hamstring strain. Piñeiro sustained the injury during the 49ers' recent victory over the Arizona Cardinals and is considered week-to-week, raising concerns about his availability for the upcoming game against the Carolina Panthers.
Matt Gay's Recent Performance and Career Overview
Matt Gay, 31, was released by the Washington Commanders after a disappointing performance in which he missed two field goals, including a potential game-winner, during a 16-13 overtime loss to the Miami Dolphins. This season, Gay has converted 13 of 19 field goal attempts, resulting in a success rate of 68.4%, which ranks him 32nd among qualifying kickers. Over his seven-year NFL career, Gay has played for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Los Angeles Rams, Indianapolis Colts, and Commanders, achieving an overall field goal percentage of 84% (178 of 212 attempts).
49ers' Kicking Situation
The 49ers' decision to sign Gay follows a series of workouts with multiple kickers, including Anders Carlson, John Parker Romo, Tanner Brown, and Cade York. Coach Kyle Shanahan indicated that the team would evaluate Piñeiro's recovery on a weekly basis, allowing them to keep Gay on the practice squad without altering the 53-man roster. To accommodate Gay's signing, the 49ers released wide receiver Russell Gage Jr. from the practice squad.
Official Statements & Responses
The 49ers officially announced the signing of Gay, with NFL Network's Tom Pelissero first reporting the move. The team expressed confidence in Gay's ability to step in during Piñeiro's absence, despite Gay's recent struggles. Coach Shanahan noted the importance of having a reliable kicker, especially with the upcoming primetime game against the Panthers.
Criticism & Opposition
Critics have pointed out Gay's inconsistent performance, particularly his difficulties with long-range kicks, as five of his six misses this season have come from over 50 yards. This raises concerns about his ability to effectively replace Piñeiro, who has been perfect on field goals (22 for 22) since joining the 49ers.
What's Next
The 49ers will begin preparations for their Monday night matchup against the Carolina Panthers, with Gay expected to take on kicking duties if Piñeiro is unable to play. The team will continue to monitor Piñeiro's recovery closely as they navigate this critical phase of the season.
