Sacramento Moves to Repeal Outdated Comic Book Ban

In Sacramento, California, a city ordinance dating back to 1949 that prohibits the distribution of certain comic books to minors is under review for repeal. This ordinance restricts comics that prominently feature crime-related imagery, including acts of arson, murder, or rape, from being distributed to anyone under 18. Although the law is rarely enforced, local advocates argue that its existence is outdated and unnecessary.

Associated Press

The Sacramento City Council committee recently voted unanimously to advance the repeal of this ordinance, which will now be presented to the full council for a vote. Lecho Lopez, a local comic shop owner, supports the repeal, emphasizing the positive impact comic books have had on his life and the lives of others. He described the law as “silly” and highlighted the cultural value of comics, stating, “A lot of good things come out of comic books.”

Associated Press

Comic book author Eben Burgoon, who initiated a petition for the repeal, echoed these sentiments, asserting that comics have the ability to “speak truth to power.” He noted that the repeal is essential to protect against a modern wave of book bans that threaten the medium.

Associated Press

The movement to censor comic books is not a new phenomenon in the United States. Jeff Trexler, interim director of the Comic Book Legal Defense Fund, pointed out that similar censorship efforts have historically targeted new media. He referenced a California Supreme Court ruling in 1959 that deemed a Los Angeles County policy banning the sale of “crime” comic books to minors unconstitutional due to its broad nature. Trexler suggested that Sacramento's ban would likely face similar legal challenges today.

Associated Press

Sam Helmick, president of the American Library Association, criticized the ban, stating, “There is no good reason” for it to remain in effect, as it contradicts modern First Amendment norms.

Associated Press

While some critics argue that comic books can incite violence, research has not established a definitive link between comic book consumption and aggressive behavior in youth. Christopher Ferguson, a psychology professor, noted that studies on television and video games have not shown clinically relevant changes in youth aggression. Benjamin Morse, a media studies lecturer, added that comics can convey positive messages despite containing violent themes, citing characters like Spider-Man who navigate complex moral landscapes.

Associated Press

• “A lot of good things come out of comic books.” — Lecho Lopez, Comic Shop Owner

Associated Press

• “These antiquated laws kind of set up this jeopardy where bad actors could work hard to make this medium imperiled,” — Eben Burgoon, Comic Book Author

Associated Press

• “there is no good reason” to have a ban such as Sacramento’s on the books. — Sam Helmick, President of the American Library Association

Associated Press

• “Every time there’s a new medium or a new way of distributing a medium, there is an outrage and an attempt to suppress it,” — Jeff Trexler, Comic Book Legal Defense Fund

Associated Press

The potential repeal of Sacramento's comic book ban reflects a broader cultural shift towards recognizing the value of comics as a legitimate form of expression. Advocates argue that comic books foster creativity and literacy, countering the outdated fears that once led to their censorship. As the city prepares for a vote, the outcome may set a precedent for similar laws across the country.

Associated Press