Full Breakdown
Investigation into the Free Birth Society: Claims and Consequences
11/23/2025, 8:05:39 PM
Overview of the Free Birth Society
The Free Birth Society (FBS), led by Emilee Saldaya and Yolande Norris-Clark, promotes the practice of giving birth without medical assistance. Despite lacking formal midwifery or medical training, they have garnered a significant following through social media, podcasts, and online courses, generating over $13 million since 2018. An investigation by The Guardian has raised serious concerns about the safety and accuracy of FBS's claims, linking their practices to infant deaths and maternal harm globally.
Criticism and Opposition
Critics argue that FBS exploits growing distrust in maternity services, fueled by scandals and concerns over medical negligence. Saldaya and Norris-Clark have been accused of promoting a dogmatic approach to free birth, labeling medical professionals as adversaries. This rhetoric has raised alarms among healthcare experts, who emphasize the importance of professional support during childbirth.
Official Responses and Statements
Following the publication of the investigation, Saldaya criticized mainstream media for what she termed "propaganda," asserting that FBS aims to disrupt conventional narratives around childbirth. FBS has also issued disclaimers stating that their content is for educational purposes and not intended to replace professional medical advice.
Verbatim Quotes
- “Across whole populations, going through labour and birth without professional support is associated with higher levels of risk for mother and baby,” — Prof. Soo Downe, Midwife
- “Saldaya has denied advising Holliday, telling students: “I didn’t know this woman at all.” — Emilee Saldaya, CEO of FBS, regarding Lorren Holliday
- “For medical advice, consult your healthcare provider,” — FBS Disclaimer
Conclusion
The investigation into the Free Birth Society underscores significant concerns regarding the safety and accuracy of their practices. As the organization continues to grow, the potential risks associated with unassisted childbirth remain a critical issue for expectant mothers and healthcare professionals alike.
